It used to be easy to find out what Republicans thought about Russia.
Four days after an airliner was shot down over the Ukraine in 2014, for example, Sen. Pat Toomey called Russian leader Vladimir Putin a “thug” who “suppressed dissent and crushed democracy.”
Weeks after Russian troops invaded the country of Georgia in 2008, Congressman Bill Shuster, R-Bedford, cosponsored a resolution urging the 2014 Winter Olympics be moved to another country. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, told the Washington Examiner in June: “[I]t would be hard to sit back and look at China and Russia and think that they’re acting in the best interest of the United States.”
But most Western Pennsylvania Republicans were less vocal on Monday, three days after the Washington Post reported that the Central Intelligence Agency believes the Russians sought to help Donald Trump beat Hillary Clinton in the presidential contest.
Although intelligence agencies previously agreed that Russians had hacked Democratic Party emails that later appeared on the Wikileaks website, they hadn’t identified a motive. Russia and Wikileaks have both denied that Russia provided the emails.
Toomey spokeswoman E.R. Anderson said the senator was too busy Monday to comment. She said he is trying to learn more about the issue before commenting. Senators must vote to confirm executive branch appointees who have had dealings with Mr. Putin, including Rex Tillerson, whose nomination for secretary of state is to be announced this morning.
Read More
A spokesman for Mr. Kelly said he hadn’t reached the 3rd District congressman for comment. Mr. Kelly has previously backed expanded trade with Russia while also stressing cybersecurity concerns.
A spokesperson for 12th District Republican Keith Rothfus sent a statement: “This matter is within the purview of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence and I will continue to look to Chairman Devin Nunes for updates.” Mr. Nunes, who is a member of the Trump transition team, said Monday that his committee would monitor investigations without undertaking its own.
Mr. Rothfus has previously warned about an “increasingly aggressive Russia,” but Monday said, “there is zero evidence that Russian intelligence influenced the outcome of the election.”
“We must be very careful to avoid any politicization of the intelligence community and its work; it was very unfortunate, for example, to hear the reports last year of how intelligence was doctored to paint a rosier picture of the fight against ISIS than was accurate,” he said.
Casey Contres, a spokesman for Mr. Shuster, said the Russians “are not a friend, and any effort of ... breaching our cybersecurity should be taken seriously.” He did not answer additional questions about whether Mr. Shuster favored a congressional investigation into the matter.
Area Democrats offered more forceful responses, although they said Mr. Trump will be president regardless of any role Russia might have played.
“It’s not about changing the results of the election,” said U.S. Rep. Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills. “It’s about confronting Russia for what they’ve done. … Every American should be concerned that a foreign government is somehow interfering with our elections.”
“A foreign power trying to influence our election is an attack on our democracy,” agreed Sen. Bob Casey, Mr. Toomey’s Democratic counterpart.
“I support the bipartisan calls for Congress to fully and completely review Russia’s attempts to interfere in our elections,” he added, citing calls for hearings by Republican leaders including John McCain and Majority Leader Mitch McConnell.
“The Trump administration must stand up to Russian aggression and that is [an] area I will focus on” in confirmation hearings, he said.
Fox News viewers heard Republican Congressman Tim Murphy’s take during a Sunday interview about his signature mental health reform bill.
The 18th District representative speculated that Democrats put out the allegations “to discredit this election.” Although Mr. Trump could call for an investigation as president, he said, “I don’t think this is the time to continue going down that road. ... [W]e’ve got to move forward and work to make our nation great again.”
It is doubtful Mr. Trump would ask the intelligence community to investigate. His transition team responded to the Washington Post report by saying the CIA was “the same people that said Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction.”
That reaction has caused consternation among national security experts.
“A president-elect has every right to disagree with the CIA,” said Michael Hayden, a former CIA head during the George W. Bush administration. “But it should be a disagreement based upon data and facts. This is just an ad hominem dismissal of a conclusion because it’s inconvenient and inconsistent with [Mr. Trump’s] pre-existing worldview. That’s really bad.”
If the Russians did seek to elect Mr. Trump, Americans should “make the Russians regret they ever did this,” he said.
Phil Williams, a professor of public and international affairs at the University of Pittsburgh, said Mr. Trump’s dismissal of intelligence reports was “the height of hubris” and worried “We see a pro-Russian Cabinet starting to emerge.”
Some Trump allies previously expressed misgivings about Russia’s purported activities.
In October, Carnegie Mellon University professor Kiron Skinner told Fox News that the hacks of Democratic emails “violate the democratic and free way of life.” Ms. Skinner, who heads CMU’s Center for International Relations and Politics, said that although the documents confirmed doubts about Ms. Clinton, discussing them “plays into the hands of the Russians.”
Ms. Skinner, who is now involved in the Trump transition effort, declined to comment Monday.
Mr. Hayden said he’d suspected the Russians were meddling “to mess with our heads. And they are doing a great job. They got a president-elect to say his intelligence service is incompetent. That’s a pretty successful covert action in my book.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533. Tracie Mauriello: tmauriello@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.