President-elect Donald Trump’s supporters filed court motions Friday to block statewide recounts in Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin.
Days before a Commonwealth Court hearing in Pennsylvania on the request for a statewide recount from Green Party candidate Jill Stein, the state Republican Party urged the court to reject the request. In a court motion made public Friday, it said a recount “puts Pennsylvania at grave risk” of not meeting a Dec. 13 federal deadline to certify its votes.
“The legal antics of that election’s fourth-place finisher suddenly meddle with Pennsylvania’s electoral participation,” attorneys for the state GOP and Trump’s campaign wrote in their court filing.
Commonwealth Court has scheduled a Monday hearing on the recount petition.
In a lawsuit seeking the recount, Ms. Stein’s campaign cited research by computer scientists suggesting possible irregularities with electronic voting machines.
Stein supporters also filed petitions for recounts in precincts around the state.
In Allegheny County, Common Pleas Judge Joseph James on Friday rejected a Republican bid to prevent a re-examination of vote totals in more than 50 Allegheny County polling places, a two-sentence order that paves the way for a partial recount of results on Monday.
In Philadelphia, recounts were underway Friday; a judge rejected petitions for recount in Montgomery County earlier this week, and Bucks County will hold a hearing Tuesday.
On Nov. 28, more than 300 Allegheny County voters petitioned the elections department to double-check the presidential and Senate results tallied by electronic voting machines in their voting districts. County officials said that was enough to trigger an examination of returns in 52 total precincts, mostly in Pittsburgh.
But Republican attorney Ron Hicks argued Friday that the county elections office could accept such petitions only while it was still compiling vote totals. After the preliminary computation was complete on Nov. 23, he said, recounts could be sought for another five days — but they had to be filed with Common Pleas Court.
“They missed the period of time, they filed in the wrong place,” he said.
Allan Opsitnick, the attorney representing the Elections Division, told Judge James, “I probably ill-advised my client” by allowing election staff to accept the petitions. But he noted that the petitions were otherwise valid, and urged the judge to allow Monday’s count. That way, he said, “Nobody will consider an appeal, nobody will gum up the works.”
But Doug Lieb, an attorney for the Stein campaign, argued that the computation process still wasn’t complete, because the county’s three-person Election Board hadn’t signed the preliminary results, as state law appears to require.
The Election Board consists of Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and the two at-large members of county council, a Republican and a Democrat. The board is now scheduled to meet on Dec. 12.
It’s not clear whether Judge James was convinced by Mr. Lieb’s argument: His order does not explain his reasoning. But at least one local election attorney, Chuck Pascal, said Mr. Lieb raised a valid concern.
“I think over the years everybody has gotten less formal about things, which may not be a good thing,” Mr. Pascal said. “What is being exposed here is that we seem to have 67 different sets of rules” — one for each Pennsylvania county. “That has to stop.”
Judge James’ order means that at 10 a.m. Monday, election officials will pull vote totals from the machines’ memory, and compare those numbers with the returns reported on election night. Elections Division manager Mark Wolosik said the process should take roughly two hours.
Then again, he cautioned, “We’ll have a room full of lawyers.”
Indeed, the dispute may not end Monday. The Nov. 28 petitions also sought a forensic examination of the voting machines, to ensure they hadn’t been hacked or tampered with.
Mr. Wolosik testified Friday that the county verifies the programming of 20 randomly selected machines each election, and will not conduct further such testing on Monday. That’s more than other counties do, but it may not satisfy recount supporters.
“It’s very important that the voting machines be examined to make sure they are properly recording results,” Mr. Lieb said.
“That’s really what the hundreds of voters who filed petitions are asking for.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.