Inside VFW Post 694, Pennsylvania Sen. Pat Toomey took friendly questions from a couple of dozen Republican stalwarts Thursday. How will he push back on attacks made by allies of his Democratic foe, Katie McGinty? What is he doing about opioid addiction?

But the reporters gathered just outside the Dormont veterans club wanted to talk about only one thing: Donald Trump. What did Mr. Toomey make of the second Trump campaign shake-up in as many months? What did Mr. Trump’s sagging poll numbers mean for his prospects?

“I think if Pennsylvania voters know ... he is a unique candidate,” Mr. Toomey said. The contests for president and Senate “are very separate races, and they will be determined on their separate merits.”

But although Mr. Toomey’s hopes may depend on voters splitting their ballots, it can be hard to tell where he and Mr. Trump part company.

Advertise with us

As he has before, Mr. Toomey said he was reserving judgment on whether to endorse Mr. Trump: “Like a lot of Republicans, I’ve just had reservations about things that he’s said, things that he’s done, positions that he’s taken.”

But both men campaign heavily on law-and-order issues at home, and criticism of the Obama administration’s policies abroad. The similarities deepened this week, when Mr. Toomey — long a supporter of global free trade — announced his opposition to the Trans Pacific Partnership. Mr. Trump has denounced the trade deal throughout his campaign.

What doubts did Mr. Toomey still harbor?

“I don’t have a checklist,” he said. “There’s not a form to fill out or anything like that. … I’m going to continue to watch [and] hope to be persuaded.”

Differences do exist, some more obvious than others.

Advertise with us

While Mr. Trump campaigns as a gun-rights absolutist, Mr. Toomey has co-sponsored a bill to expand background checks on firearm sales. He didn’t mention guns in Pittsburgh on Thursday, but he did sound less enamored of Russian leader Vladimir Putin than Mr. Trump has.

Mr. Trump has suggested he wouldn’t necessarily defend NATO states from Russian invasion: Mr. Toomey lamented that President Barack Obama’s fecklessness led to “a Vladimir Putin who … can roll through and annex sovereign states with impunity.”

But Mr. Trump and Mr. Toomey’s fates may be entwined.

Quinnipiac University polled the presidential and the Senate races here in July and August, during which time Mr. Toomey went from a 49-39 lead over Ms. McGinty to a statistical tie. Mr. Trump suffered a similar reversal, going from a 3-point lead over Democrat Hillary Clinton to a 10-point deficit.

Both Republicans performed best among men, Republicans and white voters without college educations. Ms. McGinty, meanwhile, has either erased or reversed Mr. Toomey’s leads among groups that include college-educated voters and independents.

Advertise with us

Pollster Tim Malloy called the Toomey-McGinty shift “one of the bigger ones we’ve seen.” Although he said a number of factors may explain it, “a lot of people believe Trump could drag down other ships with him. ... Republicans’ darkest fear is that it happens to someone like Toomey, who looked like a shoo-in.”

Mr. Toomey didn’t mention Mr. Trump to supporters Thursday, though he warned, “If, God forbid, Hillary Clinton and Katie McGinty win these elections, then we probably have … the permanence of the Obama agenda.” He also touted successful bipartisan legislation he co-sponsored to rein in opiate abuse: The provision requires Medicare recipients with a history of drug abuse to get painkiller prescriptions from just one doctor, filled at one pharmacy.

Mr. Toomey’s allies, too, clearly would rather discuss such matters.

“We have three months … to hammer away on policy,” said Congressman Keith Rothfus, R-Sewickley, who joined Mr. Toomey in Dormont along with U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, and state Sen. Guy Reschenthaler.

And although Mr. Trump touts his outsider status, Mr. Rothfus said, “I’d be hard-pressed to think of an item on the Better Way agenda” — a conservative legislative wish list created under Speaker of the House Paul Ryan — “that Donald Trump wouldn’t support.”

Advertise with us

Still, just this week, Mr. Trump’s campaign hired as its new leader Breitbart.com chairman Stephen Bannon. The hard-right website traffics in conspiracy theories and has bitterly opposed Mr. Ryan. Breitbart has generally treated Mr. Toomey gently, but the hiring helped distract from his message Thursday.

“Anything on our bus tour?” a Toomey aide asked after reporters queried the senator about Mr. Bannon and other Trump-related matters. “Anything on our race, not related to the presidential?”

There was a pause, then laughter. And Mr. Toomey went inside.

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com

Editor’s note: This story has been changed to reflect the circumstances under which Medicare recipients have to get presciptions from one doctor, filled at one pharmacy.