HARRISBURG — A Senate committee voted Tuesday to remove the most controversial provision of a bill that would let child sex-abuse victims sue their attackers.

By a 9-4 vote, the Judiciary Committee passed an amendment that bars the law from being applied retroactively, a move that would have enabled lawsuits by victims abused as far back as the 1970s.

The vote was a victory for opponents who complained the measure would lead to a flood of crippling lawsuits against the Catholic Church and other private institutions.

The majority of senators on the committee said they were eliminating a provision that they believed violated the state constitution.

Advertise with us

“For me, it boils down to the constitutional issue,” said Senate President Pro Tem Joseph Scarnati, R-Jefferson, who offered up the amendment but said little during the meeting and had previously declined to declare a position on the measure.

Among those opposing the move was Republican Sen. John Rafferty Jr., of Montgomery County, who Mr. Scarnati has endorsed for state attorney general,

Declaring “I am Catholic,” Mr. Rafferty called “abhorrent and disgusting” the clergy-sex abuse and church cover-ups outlined in multiple grand jury reports in Pennsylvania over the past decade.

He also said he saw no problems with the constitutionality of the provision.

“I support what the House sent over,” Mr. Rafferty said, referring to the bill that passed the House 180-15 in April.

Advertise with us

He presided over the hearing as vice chairman after chairman Stewart Greenleaf, R-Montgomery, recused himself for an apparent conflict of interest. Mr. Rafferty’s stance was shared by three other Philadelphia Democrats on the committee: Sen. Art Haywood, Sen. Larry Farnese and Sen. John Sabatina Jr.

Mr. Haywood said he would consider even more expansive language for past lawsuits — a one- or two-year window for anyone to file civil lawsuits for past abuse. The current House bill requires plaintiffs to file suits by age 50.

But the majority who voted to eliminate the provision, including Democratic Sen. Daylin Leach of Montgomery County, said such lawsuits for past abuse appeared to be unconstitutional.

“This has been a very difficult issue for me,” said Mr. Leach, the committee’s minority chairman and a lawyer. “I really want to keep retroactivity in there. I just don’t feel I can.”

Other committee members who identified themselves as non-attorneys said they had arrived at the same conclusion, relying on testimony from a hearing two weeks ago.

Advertise with us

At that proceeding, four legal experts, including Solicitor General Bruce L. Castor Jr. and two witnesses representing the Catholic Church and the insurance industry declared the provision unlawful.

“They told us, ‘Don’t do it,’” said Altoona-area Sen. John Eichelberger, explaining his support of the Scarnati amendment.

The amended bill now heads to the Senate floor, where Majority Leader Jake Corman, R-Centre, has said he wants to move it “expeditiously, most likely this week.”

Still intact is the plan to extend to age 50 the civil statute of limitations for future victims and to abolish the criminal statute of limitations so that a victim can pursue prosecution at any age.

Mr. Scarnati’s amendment also expanded some victim rights. It would allow anyone to sue most any abuser at any age, but require lawsuits against private institutions to be filed before before a victim turns 50.

Advertise with us

The amendment also makes it easier for child sex-abuse victims to sue public institutions. The House bill would have allowed such lawsuits only in cases of gross negligence. Mr. Scarnati’s amendment would require only that “negligence” be the trigger.

But those provisions won’t apply to past victims, only to those abused after the bill is enacted.

“Going forward, even after people are past age 50, they will be able to have recourse against individual defendants,” said Patrick Cawley, counsel to the Judiciary Committee. “Not just the attackers, but anyone who conspired with the attacker to facilitate that abuse, and also against anyone who was aware that the abuse was going on and did not report it law enforcement.”

The vote was a victory for the bill’s critics, including priests and officials within the Archdiocese of Philadelphia who for weeks urged parishioners to contact lawmakers to express opposition. The Catholic Conference, which lobbies on behalf of the state’s dioceses, has also been vocal in pointing out what it sees as an unfair and illegal change to state law. The Insurance Federation of Pennsylvania has also said it strongly opposes retroactivity.

Victims have vowed to push for restoring the retroactivity provision that would make abusers and private institutions liable for decades-old attacks. Gov. Tom Wolf has said he would sign the original bill.

Advertise with us

Victim advocates, the Pennsylvania District Attorneys Association, and several high-profile prosecutors have supported retroactivity for years, dating back to the first of several grand jury reports over the past decade exposing decades of clergy abuse within Catholic dioceses in Pennsylvania.

The bill’s most ardent backer in the House, Rep. Mark Rozzi, D-Berks, called Mr. Scarnati a “hit man” for the bill’s opponents.

“He was basically the hired hit man for the Catholic Church to come in here and kill this bill,” claimed Mr. Rozzi, himself a clergy sex-abuse victim who said he planned to sue after being raped as a child by a Catholic priest in Berks County.