HARRISBURG — Gov. Tom Wolf has nominated Superior Court Judge Sallie Updyke Mundy to fill a vacancy on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court that was created when former Justice J. Michael Eakin resigned in disgrace earlier this year because of his involvement in a pornographic email scandal.
In nominating Judge Mundy, 53, a Republican from Tioga County, Mr. Wolf said he will depart from the long-established tradition in Pennsylvania politics of requiring his nominee to promise not to run for the judicial seat in the next election.
Instead, the Democratic governor said Monday that his nominee could seek a 10-year term on the state’s highest court. The next election for the Supreme Court is next year, for a term that would begin in January 2018.
“There is no conditionality other than you have to be a qualified person with a good judicial temperament to merit the nomination,” Mr. Wolf said.
Mr. Wolf tapped Judge Mundy after consulting with Republicans who control the state Senate, whose members will have to confirm the nomination.
Judge Mundy replaces former Justice Eakin, a Republican from Cumberland County, who resigned his seat on the state’s highest court months after being charged with judicial ethics lapses for his involvement in the pornographic email scandal.
He was the second top jurist to step down amid revelations over the past two years that prosecutors, judges and law enforcement officials for years exchanged pornographic and otherwise offensive emails, often using state computers. Seamus McCaffery, a Philadelphia Democrat, resigned his Supreme Court seat soon after the scandal erupted in late 2014.
If Judge Mundy is confirmed by the Senate, the high court will be restored to its full, seven-member complement.
She will be the only other Republican on the court, aside from Chief Justice Thomas G. Saylor, who might have to retire at the end of this year, when he will reach the mandatory judicial retirement age of 70. A question on the November ballot asks voters to increase the retirement age from 70 to 75, which would allow Justice Saylor and another justice nearing 70 to remain on the court for five additional years.
According to a copy of her resume, Judge Mundy was in private practice for two decades before being elected to the Superior Court in 2009.
While in private practice, she focused on personal-injury cases, among other areas, according to her resume.
Aside from Judge Mundy, Mr. Wolf on Monday also nominated another two dozen people to judicial posts, including Allegheny County prosecutor David Spurgeon to the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas.
Angela Couloumbis: acouloumbis@phillynews.com or 717-787-5934.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.