HARRISBURG — Four lawyers, including the top aide to the Pennsylvania attorney general, told a Senate panel Monday that a bill to let child-sex abuse victims sue for decades-old attacks would violate the state’s constitution and ultimately fail if challenged in the courts.
“However righteous the policy goals behind [the bill], the General Assembly in its zeal cannot overrule a state constitutional right,” said Bruce L. Castor Jr., the former Montgomery County prosecutor appointed solicitor general this year by Attorney General Kathleen Kane.
A fifth lawyer said the measure was constitutional, urging lawmakers to clear its path and let the courts decide its legality. “If this body wanted to help victims, it could,” said Marci Hamilton, the lone representative of victims to testify. “It’s very simple. It’s very, very simple.”
The four-hour Senate Judiciary Committee hearing drew a packed crowd and fueled Capitol rallies before and after the proceeding. It ended without a vote or even a timetable for action; Sen. Stewart Greenleaf, a Montgomery County Republican and the committee chair, said he was unsure when the committee or full Senate would act on the bill, which already has cleared the House.
Victim advocates maintain the legislation would deliver justice for victims. But opponents, including the Catholic Church, have complained it could unfairly expose dioceses and parishes to a devastating wave of lawsuits for misconduct that occurred decades ago.
Mr. Greenleaf, who has not taken a public stance, conveyed skepticism from the outset. “Two wrongs don’t make a right,” he said. “If there is a problem with the statute, we should find it now.”
The parade of witnesses included the state’s two highest-ranking prosecutors, each with differing messages.
Ms. Kane, whose office this year announced grand jury investigations into decades of clergy sex-abuse against children in the Altoona-Johnstown Diocese, implored senators to pass the bill without amending it.
“I am asking you — I am begging you — to pass that bill immediately,” said Ms. Kane, whose suspended law license prevents her from issuing legal opinions for the office. “Do whatever needs to be done.”
Minutes later, she was followed by Mr. Castor, her top aide. He contended that the legislature could not retroactively apply the law and let victims file civil suits over decades-old abuse because the state constitution’s remedies clause bars people from being liable for claims after a statute of limitations has expired.
Supporters of the bill say that’s an inaccurate interpretation of the current law.
One law professor, Bruce Antkowiak of Saint Vincent College, also noted the state Supreme Court has not addressed this specific issue.
Ms. Hamilton, a University of Pennsylvania law professor who has studied civil statute changes and represented abuse victims in lawsuits, echoed that point during her testimony.
“The law is clear,” she said. “The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has not yet ruled on this.”
Sen. John Rafferty Jr., R-Montgomery, the committee vice chairman and the GOP nominee for state attorney general, said he was “anxious” to support the bill, but also would consider amendments. He was clearer, however, on who should vet the constitutionality issue.
Such decisions, Mr. Rafferty said, “are better made by people wearing black robes.”
Approved in the House by a 180-15 vote in April, the bill may not come up for a vote before July 1, when legislators typically break for summer until September, Mr. Greenleaf said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.