The Wolf administration filed objections Tuesday to a request by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and other news outlets that the Pennsylvania Supreme Court assume jurisdiction over a lawsuit about the state’s controversial email deletion practice.
Earlier this month the news organizations asked the high court to exercise extraordinary relief and take over the lawsuit from the lower-level Commonwealth Court, where oral arguments are pending in June.
The news outlets believe the state’s email practices violate due process rights of people seeking release of documents under the Right-to-Know Law.
Currently, 47 agencies in the executive branch allow employees to decide for themselves which emails they should keep and which should be discarded as “transitory.”
Once discarded, they are permanently deleted from state servers after five days and never can be recovered for purposes of responding to a Right-to-Know request from the public, even if the employee improperly deleted an email that was, in fact, a public record.
The state says it has the right under the law to maintain records any way it wishes and argued in its response that the Legislature recognized that government agencies are not expected “to retain every document [email or otherwise] ad infinitum.”
Read More
“Though Petitioner might genuinely believe both that it is aggrieved by [the Governor’s Office of Administration’s] records retention policy and that the issue it presents is one of immediate public importance, there is no objectively reasonable basis for this Court to agree,” attorneys for the Commonwealth wrote. “Petitioner cannot invoke this Court’s extraordinary jurisdiction merely to avoid a decision by Commonwealth court on the merits that Petitioner expects to be adverse to it.”
The Post-Gazette on Aug. 24 reported the executive branch’s email practices and the five-day permanent deletions, as well as concerns of open-government advocates.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.