If Pennsylvanians get to vote on a constitutional amendment that would add the General Assembly’s definition of what a “purely public charity” is, Auditor General Eugene DePasquale wants to make sure they have some numbers to consider.

Thursday he put out a report titled “Review of Potential Lost Revenue Due to Property Tax Exemptions” with dollar totals from 10 counties where there has already been debate over the issue, including Allegheny County.

Seeking to give a boost to what he hopes will be a “rolling freight train of debate” over the proposed amendment, he reported that $1.5 billion in property taxes were not paid in those 10 counties by organizations with charitable status.

“We thought it would be helpful for policy makers, government officials and the new governor” to have the figures, he said.

Advertise with us

The General Assembly next year will consider voting for the second time on a constitutional amendment that would ask the public if it wants to enshrine in the constitution the General Assembly’s definition of what a “purely public charity” is.

State law requires that the state House and Senate approve the proposal in two consecutive sessions, after which the proposed amendment goes to a statewide vote.

Both chambers approved the proposal in June 2013 and could do it again as soon as 2015.

Drew Crompton, spokesman for Sen. Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, the senate president pro tempore, said if both houses moved quickly, the issue could be on the ballot for voters is May.

“Is that possible? Yes,” Mr. Crompton said. “Is it likely [to be done that quickly]? No.”

Advertise with us

The legislature has about a year-and-a-half to vote on the proposal for a second time.

The proposal to amend the constitution was brought up in 2012 after the state Supreme Court ruled essentially that the state’s 1997 law, called Act 55, was not the definition of what a purely public charity is. Rather, the court ruled, the definition charities had to adhere to was the court’s own 1987 ruling out of a case in Erie known as the HUP test.

That angered some legislators, who have turned to their only solution: amending the constitution.

Mr. DePasquale’s report looked at 10 counties: Allegheny, Beaver, Bucks, Dauphin, Erie, Lackawanna, Lehigh, Luzerne, Monroe and Montgomery.

“We tried to put [the analysis] in counties where this issue is playing out sooner rather than later,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. DePasquale tried to make the case that the large amount of foregone property taxes by charities are playing a role in the financial problems in cities such as Scranton and York.

“This tax-exempt status is a major issue for local governments,” he said.