If the voters in Western Pennsylvania want “change” in Washington, they failed to produce it this year as all four of the region’s members of the U.S. House were re-elected Tuesday.

In District 3, Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, coasted to a second term over Democrat Dan LaVallee of Cranberry, and in District 12, Rep. Keith Rothfus, R-Sewickley, handily rebuffed a challenge from Democrat Erin McClelland of Natrona Heights.

Both incumbents won by margins in the neighborhood of 20 percentage points.

In the only other U.S. House races in Western Pennsylvania, Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, and Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, were re-elected without opposition in the 14th and 18th districts, respectively.

Advertise with us

Political forecasters had long ago pegged both contested races as "safe Republican" as neither Mr. Kelly nor Mr. Rothfus was challenged in the May primary and both of them faced political newcomers in the general election.

The tea leaves proved true.

The 12th District wraps around north of Pittsburgh to the east, including portions of Cambria, Somerset, Westmoreland, Allegheny and Beaver counties. Despite having more registered Democrats than Republicans, the conservative bent of the voters still leans toward the GOP.

Mr. Rothfus, 52, an arch-conservative lawyer, was first elected to the state's redrawn district in 2012, narrowly ousting incumbent Democrat Mark Critz from the seat that had been Rep. John Murtha's domain for decades.

Once in Washington, Mr. Rothfus championed small-government causes and steadfastly opposed the Affordable Care Act. He reinforced those themes during victory remarks Tuesday night to more than 80 cheering friends, family and supporters gathered at The Rochester Inn in Ross.

Advertise with us

"For the past two years, I've been pushing for common sense solutions," he said. "Stopping the harmful effects of the president's health care law, ensuring a strong national defense and a secure border. Bringing accountability to the VA for our veterans. Working to build a culture of life and protecting the freedom of conscience.

"The bosses just gave me a performance review on these last two years, and I'm happy to report that I'm going to be your employee for the next two years."

Mr. Rothfus also congratulated his opponent, Ms. McClelland, 39, the founder and former executive director of a substance abuse rehabilitation center in Blawnox, for running a "spirited campaign."

"She's been a strong advocate for her positions and she was always gracious during our encounters on the campaign trail," he said.

The 3rd District ranges from Lake Erie, down along the state’s western boundary, including portions of Erie, Crawford, Mercer, Lawrence, Butler, Armstrong and Clarion counties. Mr. Kelly, 66, the owner of an automobile dealership, was first elected to the House in 2010. He celebrated his win Tuesday night with supporters at The Mansion in Butler.

Advertise with us

His opponent, Mr. LaVallee, 26, of Cranberry, is a former deputy director with a health insurance company,

Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com.