If organized labor's all-out bid to help underdog Mark Critz's congressional bid had failed on Tuesday, Republicans would be stomping on its grave. Instead, union activists left the win reanimated with hopes they can repeat that success for other Democrats, including President Barack Obama, come the fall.
Neither proposition is entirely accurate. Even if the Johnstown Democrat had lost to fellow U.S. Rep. Jason Altmire in the 12th District primary, labor would have remained powerful, especially in places like greater Pittsburgh where it has a high density of voters. And while unions can build upon the lessons from the primary win, the landscape in November will be completely different, and even they know they cannot measure up financially with pro-GOP voices.
"We knew Mark was a major underdog and nobody thought he had a chance," said Neal Bisno, the president of SEIU Healthcare Pennsylvania. "The reason [the race] was important is the message it sends about the expectations of working people of their elected officials."
"We're excited, just like I'd be excited if we made it through the first round of the playoffs," said Frank Snyder, the secretary-treasurer of the Pennsylvania AFL-CIO, and the group's former national political field director. "It's far from the Super Bowl. We have another game to play in November."
Mr. Critz had nearly 20 unions working on his primary matchup against his McCandless foe, who was better funded, better known and represented two-thirds of the Democrats in their newly combined seat. Labor leaders said Mr. Altmire, a former UPMC lobbyist, had committed to vote in favor of President Obama's health reform bill in 2010, and when he opposed it they became obsessed with showing him the consequences.
The political arm of the United Steelworkers matched people -- the union's traditional resource -- with new technology to leverage support for Mr. Critz, especially in the last days of the campaign. Workers used virtual dialers on their personal phones to make thousands of get-out-the-vote calls, instead of being tied to old-fashioned telethon-style phone banks. The political team began testing handheld devices during neighborhood canvassing to record and process conversations with voters. Then there was the normal outreach via mailings and work site visits, all of which led every USW member in the district to be contacted seven to 11 times about the race.
"We need to use our resources better. We just don't have them anymore," USW political director Tim Waters said of the effort. "We have less human resources, less financial resources. We have to operate more efficiently."
Union political power was at its height in the mid-20th century when it represented more than a third of the country's workers. Today unions oversee less than 12 percent of the workforce nationally -- and about 15 percent in Pennsylvania -- while battling an increasingly negative public image. But a race like Altmire vs. Critz fit labor's remaining power like a glove. With a low turnout race like a primary, unions could target economic and policy interests (such as health care reform or Social Security fears) that directly impacted their members and make them a deciding factor at Democratic polls.
Things will be different in November. While Mr. Critz won by enjoying 34 percent turnout in Cambria County to the less than 20 percent in Mr. Altmire's Allegheny County base, turnout should more than triple for November's presidential vote. (Turnout in Allegheny County and statewide was 69 percent the last two presidential elections.) A bigger pool of voters, swelled with Republicans and independents, means dampened relevance for union issues.
"In an election that has generated a lot of interest and enthusiasm by the populace, the impact of the union movement itself will be undoubtedly be significantly less," said James A. Craft, a professor at Pitt's business school and a former analyst for the U.S. Department of Labor, "unless there is some consistency between the popularity of a candidate and/or a union relevant issue that is viewed in a more popular way by the general public."
Unions, which gave $400 million to Democrats in 2008, will not win the money race against GOP foes. Labor did less than $80,000 in independent spending for Mr. Critz, according to data from the Sunlight Foundation, whereas outside groups poured $475,000 into battles to defeat U.S. Rep. Tim Holden, D-Schuylkill, and $200,000 into a failed ouster of U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair.
Labor leaders expect to be outspent 20 to 1 this fall by the mostly conservative super-PACs enabled by the U.S. Supreme Court's "Citizens United" decision. To try to counterbalance some of that, the national AFL-CIO launched its own super-PAC earlier this month, called Workers' Voice, which is primarily targeting Pennsylvania and fellow swing states Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin, Florida and Nevada. The court decision allows union workers to reach out to nonunion workers for the first time.
The AFL-CIO move comes in the wake of successful efforts to force a recall vote on Gov. Scott Walker, R-Wisconsin, after approval of state legislation stripping bargaining rights from public employees, and Ohio workers winning approval of a referendum rejecting an anti-union bill from Republican Gov. John Kasich. The nationally watched Critz race was another hard-won victory.
"Labor is fighting on more fronts than it ever has in the past," said Bill Miller, a partner at Brunswick Group in Washington, D.C., and former national political director for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. "They have fights on the federal level, state level and local level. While crowing about a Democratic primary intramural fight is important for them to highlight to their membership, the reality is they have never had a moment where they are stretched as thin as they are right now."
The AFL-CIO's Snyder acknowledged the stakes. "These elections and candidates mean nothing if we cannot pass and enforce stronger labor law reform, or if we are under attack on a federal or state level every single day we go on the Hill," he said. "We're on the field every single day. But sure, we're excited any time a collaborative effort works, as this [Critz] one did."
The USW's Waters stayed at his office until 1:40 a.m. Wednesday, calling and writing to thank Critz supporters instead of going to the congressman's victory party. His political team was due to interview volunteers to see what worked and what didn't in Tuesday's victory.
"I don't see how anybody can't feel really good about this, not just because Mark Critz won, but the unifying effect for the labor movement. It brought people together who are a sleeping giant in this one small area of the country," he said. "But it's a long way to go frankly. Without a win in November it's a hollow victory."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.