Ron Paul's visit to Pittsburgh Friday was a reminder that, technically, the race for the Republican presidential nomination continues, but Rick Santorum's withdrawal this month put Mitt Romney firmly in general election mode and made Pennsylvania's once highly anticipated primary a national afterthought.
A GOP battle for U.S. Senate nomination and a handful of U.S. House and state legislative races provide a few islands of contention Tuesday but they are scattered across a sea of political ennui.
"We're anticipating an abysmal turnout," said Frank Snyder, secretary treasurer of the state AFL-CIO, the umbrella labor group that's trying to make its voice heard in several races.
"Nobody knows Tuesday is election day," Pittsburgh City Councilman Bill Peduto lamented on Thursday at a rally for Democratic state attorney general candidate Patrick Murphy.
Interest in the GOP presidential race -- and the state's primary -- dimmed considerably after Mr. Santorum, the former Pennsylvania senator, announced April 10 he was suspending his campaign. His name will still be on the ballot along with former Massachusetts Gov. Romney, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich and Mr. Paul, a congressman from Texas.
By the time Mr. Santorum withdrew, it was too late to get his name off the ballot, a fact that has little actual significance in that the Pennsylvania GOP primary is little more than a beauty contest, with no relation to how many delegates the contenders would collect in the state.
The delegates to the GOP's convention in Tampa are elected as individuals, separate from the presidential contest, and the delegate winners are not bound to any candidate.
Five Republicans are vying for the chance to take on Sen. Bob Casey in the fall. They are Armstrong County businessman Tom Smith; Bucks County U.S. Army veteran David Christian; Marc Scaringi, a former Senate staffer; businessman Steven Welch, of Chester County; and former state representative and candidate for governor, Sam Rohrer.
This race will be a partial referendum on one politician whose name is not on the ballot, Gov. Tom Corbett. Against stiff resistance from some conservatives, Mr. Corbett is credited with delivering the GOP endorsement to Mr. Welch. Tuesday's results will test whether the governor's clout with rank-and-file Republicans is as deep as it is with the party hierarchy.
On the Democratic side, the incumbent, Mr. Casey, is opposed by Joseph Vodvarka, a little known businessman.
Labor unions represent another off-ballot player who will be scored according to Tuesday's tallies, with a Pittsburgh region congressional race their most prominent test. In the new 12th Congressional district, a Democratic incumbent is certain to lose his seat. Pennsylvania lost one House seat in the reapportionment that followed the 2010 census and Reps. Jason Altmire and Mark Critz were forced into a face-off by the map crafted by Republicans.
More than half of the new district is drawn from the old 4th District, Mr. Altmire's current seat, giving him a geographical advantage. But this is a district in which labor unions are heavily involved on the side of Mr. Crist, who won his seat in a special election after the death of his former boss, Rep. John. P. Murtha.
In an increasingly conservative part of the state, both of their former districts were carried by Republican John McCain in 2008. Both candidates have voting records that place them at the conservative end of their caucus, but some union leaders contend that Mr. Altmire was less than forthright in his dealings with them before his vote against the Obama administration's health care legislation, which he ended up opposing.
Mr. Altmire sparked more intra-party friction with an ad that Mr. Critz and some other Democrats contend distorts the Critz voting record on a Republican budget measure. Steny Hoyer, the No. 2 Democrat in the House, took the unusual step last week of releasing a statement upbraiding Mr. Altmire for distorting his colleague's record.
Mr. Altmire contends that his voting record reflects the views of his constituents, but a repeat Republican challenger, Keith Rothfus, will dispute that argument in the fall. In a near-upset, Mr. Rothfus came close to making Mr. Altmire one more victim of the GOP tide two years ago.
Mr. Altmire is a member of an endangered species: the Pennsylvania Blue Dog. As recently as three years ago, that fiscally conservative caucus accounted for almost half of the state's Democratic House members. But the Republican sweep of 2010 took with it the seats of three of the state's Blue Dogs, and the other two are in jeopardy on Tuesday.
Former Reps. Chris Carney, Kathy Dahlkemper and Patrick Murphy, now one of the candidates for attorney general, were victims of that sweep.
In addition to Mr. Altmire, across the state, Rep. Tim Holden faces a well-financed Democratic challenge from Matt Cartwright, a wealthy attorney. Mr. Holden faces the same challenge as that of Mr. Critz, and, to a lesser extent, Mr. Altmire in that most of the voters of the newly drawn 17th District will be seeing his name on a ballot for the first time.
Another Murphy of a different party, Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, is defending his House seat in one of the more closely watched Republican races. He is being challenged by Evan Feinberg, a conservative Republican who had hoped to put the incumbent on the defensive over spending votes and support from some labor organizations.
But Mr. Murphy's big spending advantage has underscored his status as the favorite in the 18th District race despite the criticism he has faced from some conservatives. Mr. Murphy has never faced a really potent Democratic challenge in his decade in the House, but Larry Maggi, a Washington County commissioner unopposed for the Democratic nomination, hopes to change that in November.
The other prominent Republican House race is in the center of the state, in a conservative district, the new 4th, which opened up with the retirement of Rep. Todd Platts.
Seven Republicans are vying for the chance to defend what figures to be a safe GOP seat, but two Democrats are also contending for a place on the November ballot there.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.