Facing a GOP challenger for the first time since joining Congress in 2002, U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy defended himself Wednesday against criticism from fellow Republican Evan Feinberg and complained about the new influence of super-PACs on American politics.
Mr. Feinberg, 28, is a Peters native and former staffer to Republican Sens. Tom Coburn and Rand Paul who moved back to the area last year to take on Mr. Murphy, whom he considers too moderate for the 18th District south of Pittsburgh. Voters there have voted Republican in the past three presidential contests and were early supporters of Pat Toomey in his unsuccessful challenge of then U.S. Sen. Arlen Specter in the 2004 primary.
"This is a very conservative Republican district. Congressman Murphy has been one of the most liberal Republicans in Washington, D.C.," Mr. Feinberg said at a meeting with Post-Gazette editorial writers. "He continues to spend more and more money and funnel earmarks back to campaign contributors."
Mr. Murphy, 59, of Upper St. Clair, defended his votes on behalf of the steel, coal, nuclear and natural gas industries in southwestern Pennsylvania, which at times have put him on the same side as organized labor. That is a no-no in some conservative circles, but he said it was a fact of life in his district.
In the 18th, "You have people who are coal miners and you have people who own coal companies. ... You have people who are steelworkers and you have John Surma who runs U.S. Steel. It's a wide group, and one of the things I've always done is try to look at representing my constituency," he said.
National groups are helping Mr. Feinberg attempt to defeat Mr. Murphy in the April 24 primary, including the tea party grass-roots organizing effort FreedomWorks and the anti-incumbent group Campaign for Primary Accountability, a super-PAC based in Houston. The PACs cannot work directly with campaigns, but they are free of spending limits and can have anonymous donors, under the Supreme Court's 2010 Citizens United decision.
Mr. Murphy said the groups didn't understand issues unique to his district and called on Congress to review super-PAC rules. "It's not appropriate to have individuals doing that kind of impact from outside the district. [Voters should be influenced by] people in the district, so I am deeply concerned," he said.
Mr. Feinberg said the groups were attracted because of the same kind of concerns with Mr. Murphy's voting and spending records that drew him into the challenge. "You're never going to get money out of politics. You have to elect the right people to Congress who won't be corrupted by the money," he said.
His campaign noted later that Mr. Murphy did not complain when the American Chemistry Council spent an estimated $500,000 on ads supporting his re-election in December.
Mr. Feinberg has joined other nationwide conservative voices in criticizing Mr. Murphy's ties to organized labor, including his 2007 vote in support of so-called "card check" union organizing rules. Mr. Murphy rescinded his support three years later.
Mr. Murphy has "a long history of supporting unions, and my question is the reasoning behind it, the motivation for it. He receives the seventh-most money from organized labor of any Republican," Mr. Feinberg said, citing a 2011 Center for Responsive Politics study.
Mr. Murphy did not shy away from his work with labor, perhaps looking forward to the general election, where Washington County Commissioner Larry Maggi is set to be the Democratic challenger. He repeated that his work on behalf of steel, coal and other manufacturing and energy industries means he also has to work often with the unions that work for them.
"This district of mine is a heavy labor district. I will not turn my back and say all labor unions are bad," noting how many unions, particularly those in building trades, are headquartered in the 18th District. "Do I sit down and talk with them? Absolutely. Do I think it's wrong to talk to the unions? Absolutely not. My door is open to every group, and I need to talk to them along those lines."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.