Democratic congressmen Jason Altmire and Mark Critz continued their do-si-do Tuesday, circling around each other in another debate for the 12th District primary opponents and repeatedly finding few policy differences.
Both men are considered among the most conservative Democrats in the state's congressional delegation, and they proved it in their second televised debate of the week, refusing to say if they would campaign with their party's standard-bearer, Barack Obama, and sounding harmonious notes in favor of energy exploration and teachers unions and their opposition to the president's health care reform bill.
The candidates had to go deep into political nitty-gritty of voting procedures to find fighting ground. Mr. Altmire -- as he has done in his ubiquitous campaign commercials -- defended his vote against a conservative Republican budget proposal in 2011 that Mr. Critz voted "present" on. Mr. Critz was following the wishes of Democratic leaders trying to embarrass the GOP with the maneuver, although Mr. Altmire argues the move kowtowed to the tea party movement, a claim that earned the McCandless Democrat rebukes from his own party brass.
"I don't play games. I don't vote present. I take a stand on every vote," Mr. Altmire said.
Mr. Critz of Johnstown cited Congressional Quarterly figures showing his opponent voted 53 percent of the time with Republicans. "There's one thing about moving to the middle, it's another thing to go to the other side," the former aide said to the late U.S. Rep. John Murtha.
"I'll never run to Fox News to tell you how independent I am," Mr. Critz said later.
Mr. Altmire, 44, and Mr. Critz, 50, were locked into the April 24 primary by Republican mapmakers tasked with eliminating one of Pennsylvania's 19 congressional districts after the 2010 U.S. Census. They combined their two current districts into one covering parts of parts of Allegheny, Beaver, Cambria, Lawrence, Somerset and Westmoreland counties. Edgeworth attorney Keith Rothfus is unopposed for the GOP nomination to the seat.
Mr. Altmire enjoys certain advantages over Mr. Critz in the primary battle -- the majority of the Democratic voters in the new 12th District are from his current base around Pittsburgh's North Hills, and he has outpaced Mr. Critz in fundraising, poll numbers and Democratic committee endorsements. Mr. Critz has tried to counterbalance that by rounding up endorsements from every major union in Western Pennsylvania, from the United Steelworkers to the Service Employees International Union and the Pennsylvania AFL-CIO.
He also has repeatedly appealed to seniors, claiming Mr. Altmire's support of a balanced budget amendment would endanger funding for Social Security and Medicare, a charge Mr. Altmire denies. "It's critically important we balance the budget so we have the money in the federal budget" to pay for the programs, Mr. Altmire said at the hourlong debate hosted by WPXI-TV.
The debate followed another Monday at Pitt-Johnstown hosted by WJAC-TV.
Mr. Altmire, a former lobbyist for UPMC first elected in 2006, showed more poise on the TV set than Mr. Critz, fielding questions deftly and joking with anchor David Johnson. His Johnstown opponent, elected in a 2010 special election after Mr. Murtha's death, had to remind himself to look directly at the cameras during responses, and paused during a discussion of the war in Afghanistan to look at a monitor and say, "Hey, my commercial's on TV! Look at that."
But Mr. Critz has never claimed to have a lot of polish and has long run instead on his working-class roots and ties to labor. "What that tells people is that these are groups that know both of us and they know they can trust me, and I'm going to be out there fighting for working men and women on a daily basis," he said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.