HARRISBURG -- When Republicans pick their candidate for auditor general, they will choose between a lawmaker who spent years in accounting and a retired banking lobby executive who says his time away from politics would allow him much-needed independence.

Rep. John Maher of Upper St. Clair heads into the April 24 primary with the endorsement of the state Republican Party and financial support from the campaign committee of Gov. Tom Corbett, advantages that Frank Pinto, a former president and CEO of the Pennsylvania Association of Community Bankers, says he hopes to counter through vigorous grass-roots campaigning.

The Democratic ballot will list only one candidate, Rep. Eugene DePasquale of York County, for the office. Auditor General Jack Wagner, a Democrat from Pittsburgh, is barred by term limits from seeking another four years in office.

The auditor general examines the finances and the performance of government programs in state agencies, school districts, hospitals, state-related universities and other entities receiving state money. In February, Mr. Wagner announced he would examine a state contract for medical services after an audit of Torrance State Hospital in Westmoreland County found ethical conflicts and questionable billing. In August, Mr. Wagner reported that a performance audit of the state's wine kiosks in grocery stores found widespread operational problems and a cost to the state of more than $1 million. The state ended the program the following month.

Advertise with us

As he campaigns for the statewide post, Mr. Maher points to his experience in accounting -- his credentials as a Certified Public Accountant and his role in founding Maher Duessel, a Pittsburgh firm that audits government and nonprofit entities -- as his central qualification.

"Pennsylvania deserves an auditor general who knows how to audit," he said. "When decisions must be made about cutting budgets, I think the public agrees -- everyone agrees -- that the first thing to be cut should be waste. But you can't fight waste if you can't find waste."

While Mr. Maher, like the other candidates, praised Mr. Wagner's performance as auditor general, he said the advantage of his own experience auditing was evident when a recent warning by the auditor general about the funding of the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission reflected conclusions Mr. Maher had drawn years earlier.

Mr. Pinto, meanwhile, said the candidacies of both his primary opponent and Mr. DePasquale are flawed by their decision to seek re-election to their House seats while running for auditor general. He said if either man wins the statewide race, he will have wasted the public money needed to fill his House seat through a special election.

"You have a choice," Mr. Pinto said. "You can listen to the career politicians, all their promises, or you can listen to somebody who has an outside voice, who doesn't really give a damn about a system. All he cares about is the taxpayers' money and the accountability of that taxpayers' money."

Advertise with us

Mr. Pinto, a Dauphin County resident who worked for the state Senate in the 1970s and 1980s, is also critical of Mr. Maher for receiving the endorsement of Mr. Corbett and $25,000 in campaign contributions from the governor's campaign account.

"The fiscal watchdog over the executive branch shouldn't be handpicked by the governor," he said.

Mr. Maher said his experience as a CPA, paid by a client but responsible to the public, has given him ample experience in acting independently. And he said he has not hesitated to vote against a proposal supported by Mr. Corbett, such as the requirement that school districts receive voter approval before raising taxes beyond the rate of inflation.

Mr. Pinto argued that the head of an office staffed with accountants does not need auditing experience -- "You need a leader, you don't need another bean counter" -- and he promised to shake things up, saying he may even examine the position of auditor general, a constitutional post, to determine whether it is necessary.

"If the auditor general really can't accomplish anything -- and I'm going to make that determination after [three] years -- why do we have that position?" he said. "You would think that in an accountable, efficient government, audits would be done internally. Why do you need that extra oversight? Because you have no prosecutorial power."

Advertise with us

Both Mr. Maher and Mr. DePasquale say they would examine how environmental regulators monitor natural gas drilling, and Mr. Pinto said he wants to look at the impact fees charged to drillers. Mr. Maher also wants to examine the finances of the Port Authority of Allegheny County.

Mr. DePasquale, an attorney who served as deputy secretary of the Department of Environmental Protection, said he wants not only to save money but also to promote ways to use that savings. He proposes auditing the performance of the corrections system to seek savings that could be directed to education as well as examining transportation infrastructure funding and the effectiveness of jobs programs.

Mr. DePasquale said he has shown his concern for taxpayer money by becoming the first state legislator to post his expenses online. He said he would remain independent and fair in dealing with the Corbett administration and any future governor.

"The auditor general isn't there just to play gotcha," he said. "It's also to make sure the government is working the way it's supposed to be working. So if you go in and find a problem, you work with the administration to fix it and move forward."