HARRISBURG -- Two Democrats are bidding for the opportunity to reverse their party's unlucky streak and become state attorney general.

Former U.S. Rep. Patrick Murphy and ex-prosecutor Kathleen Kane are seeking the Democratic nomination, each aiming to become Pennsylvania's first elected attorney general from that side of the ticket.

Ms. Kane, 45, who spent much of her career prosecuting cases as an assistant district attorney in Lackawanna County, says her resume makes her the best Democrat to reverse that trend.

"Republicans have almost always put up a frontline prosecutor," she said. "If we choose the right candidate, I think it will drive out the Democratic vote by giving [voters] what they've always wanted and have always chosen."

Advertise with us

That slogan -- "prosecutor, not politician" -- emblazoned on Ms. Kane's campaign materials seeks to highlight her background and remind voters that her opponent, Mr. Murphy, is a former Bucks County congressman.

While she's taken a more traditional route of brandishing tough-on-crime credentials, much of Mr. Murphy's sales pitch centers on his military service during the Iraq War and his goal of making the office more of a bully pulpit for policy battles.

"Prosecuting cases is a big part of the job, but so is fighting the big fights," said Mr. Murphy, 38. "If you believe in Democratic principles and are willing to fight for them, you can get a lot of things done."

Those competing narratives give Democrats two distinct choices, but either will need to flesh out plans for the office in order to be successful this fall.

"They lack a theme around which voters can identify," said G. Terry Madonna, a political scientist at Franklin & Marshall College in Lancaster. "Voters expect the chief prosecutor to articulate how he's going to put the bad guys in jail."

Advertise with us

The successful Democrat in the April 24 primary will take on Republican Cumberland County District Attorney David Freed, who is unopposed for his party's nomination. Former state Auditor General Don Bailey also intends to run this fall as an independent, after withdrawing from the Democratic primary.

In interviews, the two Democrats had generally harsh words for former Republican Attorney General Tom Corbett, as well as for several controversial state legislative proposals.

While briefly commending Mr. Corbett for his handling of the legislative corruption probe that led to arrests of 25 House lawmakers and staffers, Mr. Murphy quickly pivoted to slam the former prosecutor for the time it took to bring charges against former Penn State assistant football coach Jerry Sandusky.

He and Ms. Kane criticized the use of a grand jury in that child abuse case, saying it slowed down the investigation. "Your main concern in those cases is that a violent sexual predator is taken off the streets in as little time as possible," she said.

Their GOP opponent, Mr. Freed, 41, disagreed on their opposition to the use of grand juries. "Only the prosecutor handling the case knows when the evidence is sufficient to go forward with a charge," he said.

Advertise with us

A better statewide system for tracking sex offenders across county lines, and deeper investigations of those transmitting child pornography would address some "systemic" failures, Mr. Murphy said.

As for the voter ID bill signed into law Wednesday, the Democrats described it as a constitutional violation, though one they still would uphold if elected.

They split on an ultrasound bill, which was shelved after criticism from medical professionals who said requiring a "transvaginal" ultrasound prior to an abortion was unnecessary.

Ms. Kane described that as "an illegal search and seizure" on women, but stopped short of saying she would block its enforcement. Mr. Murphy said the measure does go too far.

"That is so egregious and unconstitutional that I would not enforce it," he said. "I would defer to the Office of General Counsel and say, 'You have to handle this case.' "

Advertise with us

Despite some shared viewpoints, the dueling Democrats haven't shied from taking on each other's qualifications.

"He has never been in a courtroom in Pennsylvania," said Ms. Kane, a reference to reports that Mr. Murphy, currently employed at a Philadelphia law firm, has never taken the state's bar exam. "How's he going to defend Pennsylvania's laws when he's never prosecuted so much as a traffic ticket in Pennsylvania?"

Mr. Murphy replied by pointing to his work as a military attorney in Iraq, where he was deployed in 2003. "I think I have more of a breadth of experience than my opponent, and the experience of being in charge of 1.5 million Iraqis in the justice system in Baghdad," he said.

He countered that Ms. Kane donated $500 to Mr. Corbett's 2008 attorney general campaign, and described her husband's trucking company as anti-union. Ms. Kane's campaign says she also has donated thousands of dollars to Democratic candidates, and she does not hold any position with her husband's firm.

Ms. Kane currently holds a lead on the financial front, posting about $2 million on last week's finance reports compared to Mr. Murphy's $1.2 million. However, he has outpaced her on fundraising this year, raising $305,000 to her $58,000, and much of her campaign cash is from a $1.75 million loan from her husband.

Advertise with us

As the Democrats continue to duke it out, Mr. Freed -- whose initial Republican primary opponent, Montgomery County state Sen. John Rafferty, dropped from the race due to Mr. Corbett's support of Mr. Freed -- said he's used the spring campaign to begin canvassing the state.

He says his DA experience gives him the background to manage and budget for a large office amid few state resources. "It's about putting resources to areas of greatest need and focusing on the core mission," he said.