HARRISBURG -- The same citizen activists who pushed to rescind the Legislature's 2005 pay raise are now calling for the immediate resignation of state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin, the target of an Allegheny County grand jury.

"It is time for Justice Melvin to leave the Supreme Court, either voluntarily or involuntarily," Tim Potts, leader of Democracy Rising PA, told a news conference Tuesday.

It was disclosed last week that Justice Melvin is the target of a grand jury investigation into illegal campaign activities.

"Clearly, she is damaged goods," said Eric Epstein of Rock the Capital. "Judges should be moral icons, symbols of what is right with society. She should at least take an unpaid leave of absence before Jan. 23."

Advertise with us

That's when the high court will hear 11 appeals protesting the new House and Senate districts, which was approved by the Legislative Reapportionment Committee in December.

The critics noted that Justice Melvin's sister is state Sen. Jane Orie, R-McCandless, whose Senate district is one of the 50 that were newly redrawn. Jane Orie, along with another sister, Janine Orie, will go on trial in February, after being charged with using state employees to help elect Justice Melvin in 2009. They have pleaded not guilty.

Justice Melvin could not be reached for comment Tuesday. Critics said the other six Supreme Court members should suspend her if she refuses to step down, until the cloud over her is removed.

Chief Justice Ronald Castille could not be reached for comment. But he told the Post-Gazette last week that the usual practice in Pennsylvania is for judges to be suspended with pay if charges are filed against them. No charges have been filed to date against Justice Melvin.

The chief justice also said a four-member majority of the seven-member court could decide to suspend any justice, even without charges being filed. "That same procedure would apply to any judge or justice in the state, including me," said the chief justice, who has declined to comment on news reports about Justice Melvin and the grand jury.

Advertise with us

Mr. Epstein said that if the other Supreme Court members "are unwilling to act, and Justice Melvin is unable to do the right thing, the state House must police the court and ... instigate an impeachment proceeding." The chances of such a major move happening seem slim, however.

Besides being a grand jury target, Mr. Potts said, Justice Melvin "hasn't been performing the duties of her office. She has recused herself from participating in all criminal cases arising in Allegheny County, the second-most-populous county in the state."

Lynn Marks of Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts also has called for Justice Melvin to take a leave of absence or for other justices to suspend her.

Other critics of Justice Melvin Tuesday included Gene Stilp, best known for using an inflatable pink pig to protest the 2005 legislative and judicial pay raises, and Dennis Baylor, a Harrisburg resident who on Tuesday filed a petition with the Supreme Court. He is seeking "disqualification of Justice Orie Melvin" from sitting on the Reapportionment Commission appeal on Monday, because she would "have to determine the political fate of her sister, Sen. Jane Orie," which Mr. Baylor said is a clear conflict of interest.

In November 2005, these citizens groups were able to repeal pay raises the Legislature had approved for itself and for executive branch members. The raises had caused a public outcry and led to many incumbents retiring early or losing re-election bids.

However, the Supreme Court approved the 2005 raises for itself and the other 1,000 judges in the state. Justice Melvin was on the Superior Court at that time and returned her raise to the treasury. With benefits, Supreme Court judges make nearly $200,000 a year, Mr. Potts said. Justice Melvin takes her Supreme Court salary.