The morning after winning a seat on the state Superior Court, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge David N. Wecht will be back on the bench to hear a civil trial in his courtroom.

Even with the late night watching election results, Judge Wecht said he'd be in court by 9:15.

In January, he will assume a role as one of 15 judges on the intermediate appellate court.

"I'm very happy," Judge Wecht said late Tuesday. "It's been onerous, and I've worked hard."

Advertise with us

Judge Wecht, a Democrat from Allegheny County, was challenged in the race by Republican Vic Stabile, a civil litigator who is the managing partner of the Harrisburg office of Dilworth Paxson LLC.

In Allegheny County, where he has sat on the bench since 2003, it appeared late Tuesday that Judge Wecht's margin of victory was convincing. He also had a commanding lead in heavily Democratic Philadelphia County.

Mr. Stabile did well in his home, Cumberland County, where he sat as a Middlesex Township supervisor for more than 10 years. He also was leading in nearby Dauphin, York and Perry counties.

Although he was still watching the numbers come in, Mr. Stabile knew it didn't look good.

"I would certainly wish David a heartfelt congratulations and much success," Mr. Stabile said.

Advertise with us

Between the candidates, the Pennsylvania Bar Association's Judicial Evaluation Commission rated Judge Wecht as highly recommended, while Mr. Stabile was ranked recommended.

In rating Judge Wecht, the commission remarked on not only his love for the law, but also his teaching as an adjunct at Duquesne University School of Law, as well as at the Graduate School of Public and International Affairs at the University of Pittsburgh.

As administrative judge of the family division of the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas from 2009 to 2011, Judge Wecht implemented a new program, "One Family, One Judge," in which the same person presides over a case throughout its time in the court system.

Mr. Stabile, who handles complex civil litigation, previously worked as a clerk on the Commonwealth Court and as a litigator in the state attorney general's office. The state commission commended his pro bono work and said that Mr. Stabile is known among his peers for his integrity and strong work ethic.

In the weeks leading up to the election, the Republican Party of Pennsylvania created waves by publicizing Judge Wecht's acceptance of a $300,000 campaign donation from the Committee for a Better Tomorrow Political Action Committee, a special interest group funded by the Philadelphia Trial Lawyers Association.

Advertise with us

The state Republican Party chairman, Rob Gleason, called it an "example of justice for sale."

Judge Wecht responded to Mr. Gleason's comments Tuesday night by calling him "a spoiled child who doesn't like to lose" the fundraising game.