HARRISBURG -- In one of the evening's closer contests, Republican Anne Covey bested Democrat Kathryn Boockvar on Tuesday for a spot on the state's Commonwealth Court.

The two women, both lawyers from Bucks County, sought to fill a vacancy on the state's nine-member appellate court, which hears legal issues involving state and local government.

Ms. Boockvar, 43, led Ms. Covey, 51, for the 10-year judicial term in early tallies, but that margin narrowed and had tipped to the GOP side.

Ms. Covey will be the first attorney from Bucks County elected to a state appellate court, a victory for which her campaign credited the message she sent to voters.

Advertise with us

"She consistently said she would be a judge that would not legislate from the bench and would be a strict constructionist in following the Constitution," Covey spokesman Mike Morris said.

Ms. Boockvar pointed to fiery ads that Ms. Covey aired in southwestern Pennsylvania as the race's tipping point. Those television spots slammed the Democrat for supporting a measure to require prisons to provide voter-registration forms to newly released convicts, which the GOP candidate called frivolous.

Ms. Boockvar responded during the campaign that the legislation was never approved and would have no additional cost to taxpayers.

"I was very proud of how I ran this campaign," she said late Tuesday evening. "I believe the people of Pennsylvania deserve to consider a judge on their record, and not on misleading attacks with ominous music. Unfortunately, that's what happened in this case."

State campaign finance records showed the candidates were fairly evenly matched in their war chests.

Advertise with us

Ms. Boockvar had more than $390,000 in contributions, and Ms. Covey had received about $378,000 for her campaign coffers.

Labor issues, as well as questions on environmental policy, zoning rules and voting rights all are within the court's jurisdiction.

During a Harrisburg forum, Ms. Covey noted her background in employment law, including serving on the state's Labor Relations Board since 2002. Ms. Boockvar, who has worked with low-income clients and voting rights issues with the state's chapter of the Advancement Project, said those experiences showed her ability to balance the commonwealth's authority against individual rights.