The early fight on the ground rules for the 2012 presidential race in Pennsylvania is taking place on well-worn ground from 2008, regarding the ability of paid community organizers to register voters within the bounds of state law.
U.S. District Court Judge Nora Barry Fischer promised Wednesday that she would rule "very promptly" on an attempt by the American Civil Liberties Union to have declared unconstitutional a 2002 state law that forbids some kinds of payments for voter registrations.
The lawsuit was prompted when Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. used the law in 2009 to charge workers for the group ACORN with voter fraud.
The left-leaning Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now has since dissolved, and Mr. Zappala agreed to waive the charges pending a federal ruling, but the fight goes on. The similar group Project Vote already is organizing its paid voter registration drives statewide in 2012 and, without a federal, ruling cannot be sure other district attorneys statewide will not prosecute them, the ACLU of Pennsylvania's legal director, Witold Walczak, argued before Judge Fisher on Wednesday.
There is "an ongoing harm as these activities kick in. We could use some guidance here," Mr. Walczak said.
ACORN employed more than 300 registration canvassers in Allegheny County during 2008 and collected more than 40,000 voter registration applications. The canvassers were paid $8 an hour and worked in six-hour shifts. Although ACORN officials wanted workers to collect 20 applications per shift, they claimed there were no bonuses or quotas offered to reach those goals.
Howard Hopkirk, a senior deputy attorney general for Pennsylvania, argued against the ACLU on Wednesday, telling the judge that ACORN and other third-party registration groups were not constricted by the state law. He said they were allowed to pay wages to canvassers, just as they did in 2008, but could not pay bonuses based on the number of registrations submitted. The law frowned on such bonuses, he said, because they give workers incentive to submit fraudulent, duplicative or incorrect registrations.
While defending the law, Mr. Hopkirk said Mr. Zappala's 2009 charges were overly broad. The district attorney's "interpretation of the statute [was] incorrect," he said.
While Project Vote uses "performance goals" similar to ACORN's -- and not bonuses -- Mr. Walczak contended, he still countered that the state Attorney General's office could not provide hard evidence that the procedures led to fraud. In depositions, neither the state's chief of the registry of electors nor Allegheny County's election director, Mark Wolosik, could point to any instances of fraud from third-party registration drives. In 20 years on the job, Mr. Wolosik said, he had referred just three fraud allegations to authorities and only the 2009 ACORN matter led to charges, which were later dropped.
Mr. Hopkirk said the ACLU seemed to be arguing to get the bonuses ruled legal and thus "have its cake and eat it, too."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.