HARRISBURG -- After a lengthy committee debate on its potential costs and impacts, a measure that would require voters to show photo identification at the polls now awaits consideration by the state House of Representatives.

The bill from State Government Committee chairman Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, R-Cranberry, passed the panel Monday on a party-line vote of 15-9. Under the proposal, voters would be required to show a photo identification card issued by either the state or federal government.

Pennsylvania voters currently are only required to show an ID during their first appearance at a polling place. Under a change added Monday, a voter without a government-issued photo ID could request one from the state Department of Transportation at no cost.

Democrats on the panel criticized the measure as costly to the state and unnecessary. Rep. Steve Samuelson, D-Northampton, said requiring someone without an ID card to go to a PennDOT office before voting amounted to "a lot of hoops and a lot of hurdles."

Advertise with us

Mr. Metcalfe replied that he and others "believe the current process is irresponsible, and that we don't require people to show they are who they say they are."

Other changes in the amendment from Mr. Metcalfe would make the measure effective in January 2012, and would allow those who live in the same building as their polling place, such as those in an assisted-living facility, to only show ID if it is their first time at the polling location.

More than a dozen amendments from Democratic lawmakers were rejected during the meeting.

Both the state chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union and the county commissioners association oppose the measure, saying there is no evidence of fraudulent voting in Pennsylvania.