WASHINGTON -- Teachers unions are undermining public education, Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett told a sympathetic audience of school voucher supporters here Monday.

As mostly union protesters chanted outside the Washington Marriott denouncing Pennsylvania's pending bill that would create a statewide school voucher program for low-income students, Mr. Corbett touted the proposal as a way to improve failing schools by making them compete for students.

Teachers unions, Mr. Corbett said, are among the main reasons public education has declined in quality. He said the rise in unions turned education into a "labor-management model."

"School districts began to focus too much on contracts and too little on curriculum," he said. "It's not a system that makes schools work for children."

Advertise with us

Opening the National Policy Summit of the American Federation for Children and the Alliance for School Choice, Mr. Corbett told of his own experience as a high school history and civics teacher and said he wants to be clear that his plan is not an attack on teachers.

But it is aimed at teachers unions, which Mr. Corbett said needlessly protect teachers who just hang on for a couple of years until they get tenure. Union last-in, first-out policies might be useful in industries where workers do similar rote jobs, but in teaching, Mr. Corbett said, it doesn't properly reward talent -- or punish incompetence.

"We need an educational workforce of strivers, not survivors," he said.

The pending voucher bill would give low-income parents vouchers equal to the amount of state per-student spending for use at private or parochial schools if they choose to remove their students from public schools. Foes say it will drain still more funding from already squeezed public schools.

Outside the hotel, several dozen union-backed protesters marched and chanted: "Say no to vouchers; save our students." Organizers said about 50 of the protesters came from Pennsylvania. Others came from Wisconsin and the D.C. area to oppose the appearances of Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker and former D.C. Schools Chancellor Michelle Rhee -- both of whom have staged high-profile battles with unions.

Advertise with us

About 10 counter-protesters from the conservative organization FreedomWorks held up signs supporting the Pennsylvania bill.

As American Federation for Children chairwoman Betsy DeVos was introducing Mr. Corbett, a protester briefly interrupted her with shouts before being escorted from the luncheon.

Mr. Corbett said he understood that the proposals were "threatening" to some people, but the vocal foes of school choice simply need to learn more about it.

"I think we're talking to the choir," Mr. Corbett said at the start of his speech. "I wish we could have the woman who was just in here to sit down and talk."

The bill, known as Senate Bill 1, is pending in the state Senate, where Republicans and some Democrats favor vouchers. But there's not as much support for them in the GOP-controlled House, where members prefer offering tax credits of as much as 95 percent to businesses that provide scholarships to children whose families earn less than $75,000 a year.

Advertise with us

That concept also is included in Senate Bill 1, but in the House there is momentum to expand the program by offering more tax credits. House Republicans see the tax credits program as an alternative to vouchers.

Caucus spokesman Stephen Miskin called the program a successful public-private partnership.