HARRISBURG - An intense, ongoing clash between House members over construction wage rates has blocked action on a bill to create "public-private partnerships" to improve roads, bridges and rail in Pennsylvania.
The so-called P3 bill, sponsored by Rep. Rick Geist, R-Blair, has a controversial provision requiring private firms that build public-private transportation projects to pay their workers the "prevailing wage" earned by workers in the largest town in the county where a project is being built.
Many construction firm executives and chamber of commerce officials have complained for years that "prevailing wage" amounts, in reality, to labor union wages. Critics contend such pay rates are higher than those for nonunion workers and higher than wages paid in many areas of the state, especially rural areas, and thus unnecessarily drive up the cost of construction. Union officials said their workers are well-trained and the best able to do quality construction, and should be paid properly.
The House is now run by Republicans, and many of them are conservative and anti-union in political philosophy. They have criticized the level of state spending and think taxes have been excessive.
House officials said that during a closed-door GOP caucus Tuesday a sharp split developed between lawmakers who wanted to delete the wage requirement from the P3 bill and those who didn't. Mr. Geist had said he was confident the bill would be debated on the House floor Tuesday, but that never happened and it isn't known when it will happen.
Gene Barr of the Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry said many people "have concerns over the prevailing-wage requirement and about anything that looks like it will expand it in Pennsylvania. It would improve the view of a lot of people toward that bill if that requirement were removed."
For decades, the rule has required that the higher wages to be paid on projects costing more than $25,000, he said. Some school officials have also complained about the added cost to their projects.
Mr. Geist is anxious to enact the bill, saying it could be used to add new toll lanes to a number of roads in the state, including the Parkway East from Downtown Pittsburgh to the turnpike and on part of the Mon Valley Expressway, as well as adding passenger service to the Allegheny Valley freight line.
In a P3 project, a private developer would contract with PennDOT and then would put tolls or charges on the added lanes, new bridge, rail line or parking garage, in order to pay for construction and maintenance.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.