HARRISBURG -- Some welfare recipients soon could have one more hurdle to clear in order to receive benefits.

The state House in a 164-23 vote Wednesday night approved a bill requiring drug testing for welfare applicants who are on probation and parole for drug offenses or who had been convicted within five years.

Twenty percent of recipients with drug offenses would be retested randomly every six months under the bill sponsored by state Rep. Garth Everett, R-Lycoming. Those who fail would get another chance provided they agree to treatment, but those who fail a second time would lose benefits for a year.

Meanwhile, the House in a 159-29 vote passed a separate bill that would require people transitioning off the welfare rolls to repay special-assistance funds if they don't stay employed at least 18 months. The funds now are provided as grants of up to $2,000 for required work tools, uniforms, training, bus passes, child care or other necessities to enter the workforce.

Advertise with us

Both bills now head to the Senate.

Under Mr. Everett's bill, the benefit loss applies to the portion of food stamps and cash assistance that goes to the individual. Benefits would still be provided to the rest of the family.

Still, advocates for the poor are concerned that children would suffer from decreased benefits to their families.

"These children are dependents of people with enormous problems in their lives, of which drug problems might be one. It's already true that they're innocent victims of their families' dysfunction," said Ken Regal, co-founder of the Allegheny County advocacy group Just Harvest. "If we force out them of the system or discourage them from with measures like this then we just add another layer to the victimization and misery of their dependents."

Some eligible recipients might be dissuaded from applying for benefits because they fear a false positive test result, he and other opponents said.

Advertise with us

Supporters of the bill say it's fair to have eligibility requirements for people who are receiving government money.

"They're getting tax money free of charge. To ask that they verify that they're eligible isn't too much to ask," said Rep. Dave Reed, R-Indiana, during a telephone interview.

Mr. Everett said the drug tests could cost $190,000 in the first year. He could not estimate how much the state might save by ending benefits for those who fail the tests.

"If we break the cycle [of drug use] and these folks become productive citizens, we've obviously saved the citizens of the commonwealth hundreds of thousands of dollars in welfare benefits down the line," he said during floor debate.

Meanwhile Wednesday, Rep. Mark Cohen, D-Philadelphia, led opposition to a separate reform proposal that essentially transforms special assistance grants of up to $2,000 into loans that would be forgiven after 18 months of employment. He said the legislation unfairly punishes people who try to become self-sufficient but fail.

Advertise with us

"Failing to get out of poverty is a major punishment in and of itself. They don't need extra punishment such as this," Mr. Cohen said during floor debate on Tuesday.

Bill sponsor Todd Stephens, R-Montgomery, said most recipients will never have to repay the loans because their efforts at self-sufficiency will be successful.

The bill was prompted by a 2009 state audit that revealed mismanagement in the $200 million-a-year program. The audit found instances where invoices were altered, where no receipts justified expenses and where grants weren't used for eligible expenses.

The measures that passed Wednesday are part of a larger GOP welfare reform package aimed at rooting out fraud in order to shift money to education programs that were cut in Gov. Tom Corbett's proposed budget, said Mr. Reed, who is leading the charge.

Other bills in the package would require photo identification to use benefit cards; prevent tobacco purchases with cash assistance benefits; limit reimbursement for travel to methadone clinics; and require benefit applications to be filed at the closest assistance office rather than farther regions that offer better benefits because of higher costs of living.