HARRISBURG -- A divided House on Monday approved a controversial limitation on plaintiffs' ability to collect civil judgments, but the debate is far from over.

To be enacted, the legislation also must be approved by the Senate, where competing legislation has been introduced.

The House bill would protect wealthy defendants from having to pay the bulk of jury awards when co-defendants are found to be more culpable but less able to pay.

It provides exemptions for cases involving intentional torts, intentional misrepresentation, for some liquor code violations and for defendants who are liable for more than 60 percent of damages.

Advertise with us

The legislation "will restore an element of justice that for too long has victimized large and small employers," said Rep. Curt Schroder, R-Chester, who sponsored it. The current rule "creates unfairness and uncertainty in our civil justice system and wreaks havoc on those trying to bring economic hope and opportunity to Pennsylvania."

Health care and business leaders largely support the measure while trial lawyers oppose it.

Monday's debate was bogged down in motions from Democrats seeking to dilute the bill with amendments that would add exemptions. Those members also attempted to amend the bill last week but were shut down by Majority Leader Mike Turzai, R-Bradford Woods, who used a procedural move to cut off debate.

The House approved the bill 112-88, with most votes along party lines.

Rep. Kate Harper, R-Montgomery, broke ranks, saying the change would cause defendants in medical malpractice suits to turn against each other rather than litigate together.

Advertise with us

"Hospitals and medical centers will have a financial incentive to point the finger of blame at the doctor," she said. "The doctors will need to buy more malpractice insurance. ... It will be expensive and it will hurt."

The bill now heads to the Senate, which also is considering a bill that would hold a civil defendant harmless if a plaintiff is found to bear a greater share of responsibility for damages.

Some who testified at a public hearing Monday said they don't like either bill.

The current system appropriately compensates victims when some defendants can't pay, said Bethany Evans, legislative director for the AFL-CIO.

"Our position is simple," she said. "Make the victim whole."

Advertise with us

The current system worked for Kyle Hoff, a Montgomery County resident who was paralyzed in 2007 at a construction site where an inadvertently activated boom caused a piece of equipment to topple onto him.

The company employing the boom operator had only $1 million in liability insurance, far less than his medical care would cost, he testified.

Joint liability allowed Mr. Hoff to recover a greater portion of damages from a settlement with the manufacturer of the boom, which lacked a safety device that would have prevented the accident. The details of the settlement were not available because of a nondisclosure agreement.

"It's not about a search for deep pockets, as some would have you believe. Joint liability is a safety net, a simple matter of right and wrong when a group of defendants is liable," Mr. Hoff testified.