HARRISBURG -- Pennsylvania's liquor stores have come a long way since the end of Prohibition in 1933, when Gov. Gifford Pinchot decided the new state-owned shops should be set up like drug stores, with customers forced to step up to a counter and ask a clerk to fetch the desired products off shelves in the back.

"Gov. Pinchot's perception was that alcohol was a drug, and he wanted people to feel the same way they did when they walked into a drug store to buy cough medicine,'' said Joe Conti, a former restaurant/tavern owner and state senator who is the chief executive officer of the Liquor Control Board's empire of 620 stores and 5,700 employees.

State Rep. Paul Costa, D-Wilkins, can recall those old days. "I called it the 'shoe store effect,' like when a shoe salesman goes to the back of the store to get a customer a pair of shoes.'' At a recent House hearing, he said the system "has come a long, long way in the 13 years I've been in the Legislature. It's really been evolving, even without the possibility of privatization.''

There it is -- the 800-pound gorilla.

Advertise with us

LCB Stats

Board members: Chairman P.J. Stapleton, Tom Goldsmith and Robert Marcus, named by governor

Salaries: $72,000 for chairman, $69,000 for other two

Chief executive officer: Joe Conti, salary $156,700

Formed: 1933 by Gov. Gifford Pinchot, who favored temperance and aimed to make buying alcoholic beverages as inconvenient as possible

Advertise with us

Employees: 5,700, most members of one of three unions

Retail stores: 620

Warehouses: Three, near Pittsburgh, near Philadelphia and near Scranton

Annual sales: $1.9 billion last year

Annual profit given to state general fund: about $100 million

Advertise with us

Annual taxes given to general fund: about $400 million

Current price markup on all items: 30 percent

Current taxes on items: 18 percent Johnstown flood tax and state sales tax

Gov. Tom Corbett and House Majority Leader Mike Turzai, two conservative Republicans from the North Hills of Pittsburgh, are strongly pushing to turn the state-owned and operated stores over to private businesses, while unions representing the employees and some Democratic legislators are resisting, insisting that "modernization" not privatization, is the best solution.

Mr. Corbett and Mr. Turzai want to get Pennsylvania out of the wine and liquor business, saying it's not a core function of government. In early March, Mr. Corbett said he's "committed to a study that looks at how best to get us out of a business we should never have entered. I'm talking about the liquor business. This isn't about the money. It's about the principle. Government should no more run the liquor stores that it should run the pharmacies and gas stations.''

Advertise with us

So much for the Pinchot drug store model. Mr. Corbett has gotten support from conservatives and a recent poll that showed 66 percent of the respondents favored private operation of liquor stores. And principle or not, there is a money crisis in the form of the state's $4 billion budget deficit.

Mr. Corbett is the third governor in the last 30 years to go down this road, and he hopes to fare better than Gov. Dick Thornburgh did in the early 1980s and Gov. Tom Ridge did in 1997.

Dueling statistics

Mr. Turzai thinks it's reasonable to figure the state could get a one-time cash infusion of up to $2 billion from privatization -- by leasing as many as 750 retail liquor stores -- the current stores plus 130 new ones -- and creating 100 new wholesale licenses for the private market. He plans to introduce a bill to do so in May.

He said a 1997 Price Waterhouse study put the figure in the $600 million to $1 billion range, and Gov. Ed Rendell later estimated $1.5 billion from leasing the stores, so he argues that $2 billion seems reasonable now. Mr. Corbett is using Public Financial Management of Philadelphia, originally chosen by Democrat Rendell for various studies, to examine the pros and cons of privatization. The firm's fee for this latest work has not been disclosed but a report is expected by July.

Advertise with us

State store union leaders fear privatization would threaten thousands of their members' jobs.

Wendell Young of the United Food and Commercial Workers, which represents 3,500 clerks in state liquor stores, disputes the claim that private business can do a better job of selling liquor than a state agency with 78 years of experience.

The feisty Mr. Young said liquor stores shouldn't be turned over to "privateers'' and scoffs at the idea the state could get anything like $2 billion from leasing the stores, saying it's based on faulty studies and "bad math.''

Based on license fees in other states, Mr. Young says privatization wouldn't get the state more than about $300 million and it would lose the annual profits it now gets.

He said he doubts most licenses would sell for more than $300,000, except for perhaps a few areas of dense population. And in small rural areas, licenses may not sell for more than $50,000.

Advertise with us

He's also concerned that his union members would have trouble finding good paying jobs in privately run stores.

Also fighting privatization is W. David Wanamaker of the Independent State Store Union, which represents 700 LCB store managers. He can't understand why the governor wants to spend "even one penny of taxpayer dollars'' on a privatization study of a system "that has not cost the state one penny in more than 77 years.''

Privatization opponents often cite the $1.9 billion in annual wine and spirits sales that the LCB makes, enabling it to give the state's general fund $400 million a year in tax receipts and another $100 million in profits.

Those funds result from a 30 percent markup on the thousands of products the stores retail, plus money from the state sales tax and the 18 percent "Johnstown flood tax'' enacted in 1936 to bail out flood-ravaged Johnstown (and yet still in effect).

Many legislators don't want to give up that money by privatizing. Mr. Turzai insists the tax revenue would still roll in under a private system.

Advertise with us

The renewed push for privatization has sparked increasing debate at the Capitol. "I call it a battle," said Mr. Young.

Besides the money issue, the privatization debate also hinges on "societal impacts" -- do state store clerks, as LCB backers claim, do a better job of keeping liquor out of the hands of underage buyers than private stores?

Matt Brouillette of the conservative Commonwealth Foundation says no. He said a study by Duquesne University "found absolutely no link between underage drinking and the level of state control.'' He argued that employees of private liquor stores "have just as much incentive to refuse alcohol to minors as public employees,'' because private stores could lose their liquor licenses or even face criminal charges for serving teens.

Gov. Pinchot wouldn't recognize the place

While the Pinchot-style counters were removed in the 1980s, the pace of change really accelerated when Mr. Rendell became governor in 2003.

Advertise with us

Then-LCB Chairman Jonathan Newman worked hard to improve the selection of wines in state stores. Sunday store hours were added on a limited basis.

The LCB has come under criticism for spending money for marketing, sizeable salaries and some of its contracts. The agency says the money is well spent, and denies it will use its profits to fund a campaign against privatization.

Legislators are concerned about a steep increase in the cost of a contract with Deloitte for computer software work. It has jumped from the original $25 million to $60 million, in part because LCB in-house staff didn't have sufficient information technology skills and Deloitte had to do more work.

A staffing change caused a big stir in late 2006, when Mr. Newman resigned in protest over the selection of Mr. Conti to the newly created post of CEO, at a salary of $156,700. Mr. Newman argued the new post wasn't needed, but Mr. Rendell supported Mr. Conti, and elevated Mr. Stapleton to chairman in January 2007

"The governor told me to run the liquor system like a business and provide Pennsylvania with as much profit and taxes as possible,'' said Mr. Stapleton. There are two other LCB members, former Easton Mayor Tom Goldsmith and Indiana County lawyer Robert Marcus.

Advertise with us

One change under the Stapleton-Conti regime has been an increase in advertising -- on billboards, radio, in some newspapers and magazines and at some major and minor league sporting events. Critics have questioned why a monopoly needs to advertise.

The liquor board has an ad contract for up to $5.9 million a year; $1.6 million of that goes to the Neiman Group of Harrisburg, which designs the print and radio ads, and the rest to Harmelin Co. of Philadelphia, which makes the media buys.

Neiman Group's CEO is Tim Reeves, who was press secretary to Gov. Ridge in 1997 when he tried unsuccessfully to privatize the state stores. The current Neiman contract is all for retail marketing and nothing involving privatization, Mr. Reeves stressed.

Mr. Conti insisted that no advertising money will be spent on the fight against privatization -- "not one cent,'' he said in an interview.

Flap over kiosks

Advertise with us

Another controversial move came in 2010, when the LCB began putting high tech, self-serve "wine kiosks" in 30 grocery stores around the state, which may expand to more stores, including Wal-Marts.

Just one firm, Simple Brands of Philadelphia, bid in 2009 to supply the kiosks. LCB officials denied that it was a contract designed so that just one firm could fulfill the specifications, but two of Simple Brands' investors had political ties to then-Gov. Rendell.

Mr. Conti said that situation had nothing to do with Simple Brands getting the contract. He said it's the only firm with the necessary technology.

The store managers union blasted the kiosks as "Rube Goldberg'' devices when they broke down during the lucrative Christmas-New Year's holidays and had to be pulled out of service.

Other changes proposed or ongoing include:

Advertise with us

• Seeking to expand Sunday hours to all state stores, instead of the current limit of 150, and expand Sunday hours from noon until 9 p.m. instead of the current 5 p.m. closing.

• Holding special events to focus attention on wines, such as an event this month at the Philadelphia International Arts Festival to showcase French wines.

• Shipping wine directly from wineries to a customer's home, rather than forcing the buyer to go to a state store to get it. Mr. Stapleton said, however, the state first must figure out a way to ensure that under-age teens can't make such purchases over the Internet, and that the state collects all the taxes it's owed on direct delivery purchases.

• Totally redesigning the look of a few stores, starting with three in Eastern Pennsylvania and one in Harrisburg, with the first Western Pennsylvania store planned for 2012 in McIntyre Square in the North Hills of Pittsburgh.

Stay tuned

The battle over privatization probably won't really get under way until after a new state budget is adopted in June. The study being done for Mr. Corbett may not be ready until July, when legislators may be on their summer break. So fall is the most likely time for a serious debate on Mr. Turzai's legislation, to be called House Bill 11.