State Sen. Jane Orie's lawyer appealed her case Friday to the state Superior Court, as promised, likely postponing her retrial on corruption charges scheduled for Monday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
Attorney William Costopoulos said in the appeal that Common Pleas Court Judge Jeffrey A. Manning was wrong to declare a mistrial in March and to not recuse himself.
Judge Manning this week denied Ms. Orie's request to dismiss the case on double jeopardy grounds, calling the claim "frivolous." He also denied a request to step aside.
Mr. Costopoulos asked that those decisions be reversed, saying the judge's ruling on the double jeopardy issue is a "gross abuse of discretion" and that he should be removed because "a reasonable question has been raised" as to his impartiality, considering that he accused the defense of forging documents.
Ms. Orie, 49, of McCandless, is charged with using her staff to do campaign work for her and her sister, state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin. A third sister, Janine Orie, an aide to Justice Melvin, also is charged. Justice Melvin has not been charged but is under investigation.
In a 28-page opinion on Tuesday, Judge Manning ripped the defense team for entering forged documents as evidence, which led him to declare the mistrial on March 3.
He said the documents, including apparently doctored signatures of Ms. Orie's chief of staff, were in possession of the defense until the last day of the trial and that responsibility for them is hers, not the district attorney's office or the judge's staff.
Mr. Costopoulos said in his appeal that such comments show he's biased to the prosecution.
"Judge Manning has alleged that a fraud was perpetrated on the court by virtue of the allegedly fabricated documents, which is highly inflammatory and prejudicial evidence," he wrote. "He should not preside at any further proceedings in this case, especially any retrial."
On the double jeopardy issue, Mr. Costopoulos said Superior Court should review whether the appeal is truly "frivolous." He also said retrial should be barred because Judge Manning acted too quickly to "exercise the extreme judicial remedy" of declaring a mistrial during jury deliberations.
Judge Manning had denied a request to postpone the second trial, but he said if Mr. Costopoulos appealed the double jeopardy issue he would push it back until Superior Court makes a decision.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.