At this point in the 2008 campaign cycle, Pittsburgh's own Tom Vilsack, the former governor of Iowa, had not only declared his candidacy for president, he had run a months-long campaign before dropping out of the nomination sweepstakes.

This time around, former Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty made news with the late-March announcement that he was forming an exploratory committee in anticipation of a run for president. While several other Republicans have made their presidential ambitions clear, he was the first major GOP candidate to take even that preliminary step in the race for the White House.

The formal part of the campaign is starting late compared with the recent past, and it's on a path that has yet to be charted. Not only are the dynamics among the candidates uncertain, but less than a year before the first votes will be cast, the dates and sequence of contests in which they will compete remain fluid.

Republican National Committee officials are in negotiations with Florida lawmakers to try to amend a Sunshine State law that would leapfrog its voters to the front of the nominating process. The leaders of the Republican parties in South Carolina and Iowa called this week for the GOP to pull its convention from Tampa if Florida fails to concede.

Advertise with us

New Hampshire, ever vigilant of its role as the first primary state, is once again holding off on scheduling its presidential preference contest until it can be sure it is the first primary. And Iowa Republicans are ready to shift their caucuses, now tentatively set for Feb. 6, 2012, to preserve its status as the starting line for the presidential race.

"Iowa is going to be first in the nation,'' said Casey Mills, a spokesman for the Iowa Republican Party. "If other states jump the calendar again, so will Iowa.''

It was supposed to be simpler. After the 2008 election, officials of the national Republican and Democratic parties got together and agreed on a proposal to bring some order to the competition among states trying to magnify their individual voices in the nominating process to avoid the game of chicken played out in that cycle. New Hampshire waited until November 2007 to schedule its traditional primary. Secretary of State William M. Gardner serenely suggested that he would have been willing to back the primary into 2007 if need be, to guard the Granite State's status. Thousands of political operatives, activists and reporters got to celebrate New Year's Day 2008 in Des Moines, two days before caucuses that had been moved up to Jan. 3 from their traditional date in February. Florida and South Carolina vied for bragging rights as the first primary in the South for months through 2007, before Florida yielded to the Palmetto State.

Last year, national Democratic and Republican party officials agreed on a calendar in which no state but Iowa, New Hampshire, Nevada and South Carolina would be permitted to hold primaries or caucuses before March. And most states seem to be prepared to abide by the calendar restrictions.

A matter of momentum

Advertise with us

But Florida law specifies that its primary should take place on the last Tuesday of January; that's Jan. 31 next year. The chief penalty for renegade states is a loss or elimination of delegate strength, a strong but not overwhelming weapon. Delegates are the main currency in primary and caucus contests, but not the only one. Particularly in the early states, the publicity and momentum from a victory can be far more important.

In Iowa, no actual delegates are selected in the hard-fought competitions of caucus night. But an Iowa victory can provide the national attention and resulting fund raising boost to propel a candidate through later states and on to the nominating convention.

Iowa and New Hampshire have the ability to be agile, if need be, in shifting their dates. That's because the Iowa caucuses are a party-run event, not restricted by state law, and the New Hampshire date is left to the discretion of Mr. Gardner, its longtime secretary of state. In Florida, as in many other states, a date change would require legislation.

David Bishop, a spokesman for Sen. Mike Haridopolos, the Florida Senate president, said that the Republican senator is interested in enhancing Florida's role but is willing to compromise and take a place behind the four designated early states.

"Florida doesn't want to go first, it wants to go fifth,'' he said.

Advertise with us

Such a shift would still require compromise, as the RNC rules give 46 states the option to schedule contests as early as March 1.

"Negotiations are continuing. The legislative session doesn't end until May, so there's some time,'' Mr. Bishop said.

A Florida shift of two weeks might accommodate Iowa and New Hampshire's traditional primacy, but could still conflict with Nevada and South Carolina, now penciled in for Feb. 18 and Feb. 28.

"The only date we have now is the second Tuesday of March; that's town meeting day,'' said Mr. Gardner. "When we have to move up will depend on the other states, Florida and Arizona in particular. I don't expect to have a date until sometime next fall.''

Some Arizona Republicans have asked the state's governor to exercise her prerogative to move the state's primary ahead. A spokeswoman for Gov. Jan Brewer said, however, that she has no plans to advance the date, now set for Feb. 28, a point that would still leave the state out of compliance with RNC rules.

Advertise with us

So while most of the early attention has focused on Florida's plans, a number of other states must still make changes, either in dates or rules, to bring themselves into compliance. The RNC/DNC accord also specifies that primaries and caucuses that occur in March must use proportional representations, rather than a winner-take-all, systems in awarding delegates, a requirement that would demand rules changes in several other states.

Schedule can influence race

Republican party officials have repeatedly expressed confidence that negotiations with the various state parties would smooth all this out. But on Thursday, Karen Floyd, the South Carolina GOP chairwoman, voiced frustration with her Florida counterparts, demanding that the party's national convention be moved from Tampa.

Matthew Strawn, the Iowa Republican chairman, released a statement last week endorsing the South Carolina call.

"The contempt that Florida legislators held not only of the RNC 2012 rules, but also for the RNC members who approved these rules, is astonishing,'' he wrote. "To reward this arrogance with our national convention is a real disservice to the Republican activists, donors and elected officials nationwide who support the RNC.''

Advertise with us

Kirstin Kukowsi, a spokeswoman for the RNC, shrugged off the notion that the convention would move.

"The convention will be in Tampa obviously,'' she said. "At the same time we're going to enforce the rules agreed to by the RNC and the DNC.''

Beyond the travel plans of politicians and reporters, the order of the nominating state could have significant tactical consequences for the candidates. The particularly strong influence of social conservatives in Iowa and South Carolina, for example, could boost the chances of potential candidates such as Mike Huckabee or of a long shot, such as Rick Santorum. An earlier spotlight on Florida, on the other hand, could enhance the chances of a better-funded candidate, such as Mitt Romney.

One of the crucial early developments of the 2008 Democratic presidential race involved the major candidates' joint pledge to avoid primary campaigning in Michigan and Florida after both had flouted party rules by moving their primaries up into January. David Plouffe, President Obama's campaign manager, recounts in his campaign memoir, "Audacity to Win,'' how he and his opposite numbers in the John Edwards camp had quietly colluded in bringing pressure on the Hillary Clinton campaign to join in the boycott. Had those two big states been in play in the early Democratic competition, the better known former First Lady, with strong ties to both, might have entered the subsequent Super Tuesday contests in a commanding position.

Iowa Republicans are jealous guardians of their nominating role, but in one sense, no one has done more to undermine the unique gatekeeper status of the GOP caucuses than the Iowa Republican Party itself. The key Iowa Republican event in pre-primary years is a loosely regulated straw poll held in Ames. The price of a ticket is a virtual poll tax that allows attendees to vote for the candidates; the better-funded among them bus in and buy tickets for their supporters. Established as a fund-raising event, it has emerged as a significant, highly competitive event for the Republican field.

Advertise with us

Straw polls gaining favor

In 1999, six months before any caucus votes were cast, disappointing showings in the August straw poll essentially ended the candidacies of Lamar Alexander, former vice president Dan Quayle and former transportation secretary Elizabeth Dole.

"In 2007, [now governor, then senator Sam] Brownback of Kansas was essentially setting himself up to be the conservative alternative to Romney. Huckabee came out of nowhere to beat him in the straw poll and basically bounced Brownback from the race,'' said Dennis Goldford, a political scientist at Drake University and the co-author of "The Iowa Political Caucuses: The Making of a Media Event."

"It's about as contrived as can be, but it matters."

That lesson appears to have made an impression on Florida's GOP. This year the party is planning an ambitious September straw poll with the intent of attracting similar national attention to a gathering of thousands of party activists from across the state. No delegates will be chosen at the event, but Florida organizers hope that in the only semi-rational world of the presidential nominating process, their straw poll will emerge as a significant political milestone.