After nearly three weeks of trial testimony, the jurors in the Orie case gathered Thursday morning to weigh what they had been presented in court. Binders of evidence were stacked around the jury room, promising lengthy discussion and deliberation.

The process, however, came to a halt shortly after 11 a.m., when court officials entered the room, packed up the evidence and removed it.

"We knew something was up," one of the jurors would say.

A short while later, as some jurors napped and others played Scrabble, Judge Jeffrey A. Manning came into the room to explain to the 7 men and five women that because of questions he had regarding the authenticity of signatures on some of the documents entered as evidence, he was declaring a mistrial.

Advertise with us

They could go home.

"[Judge Manning] brought the documentation up and he explained to us, 'This is what it was -- I can't just say disregard this one document, because it would throw everything else into question,' " said a male juror who asked not to be identified.

The jurors, who had been sequestered during the deliberations, were given back their cell phones and immediately began looking up news accounts of the case. One quote in particular -- in which Judge Manning said, "Ray Charles could see that signature was doctored" -- caused them to burst into laughter.

But, in the end, it was no laughing matter. Twelve Allgheny County residents, and the alternates who served with them, had dutifully invested themselves in the trial of state Sen. Jane Orie, R-McCandless, and her sister, Janine Orie, on charges of using the senator's staff to do campaign work on state time.

The case had gone to the jurors Wednesday afternoon. But a few hours Wednesday and Thursday morning did not provide much opportunity to get started, they said after the mistrial was declared.

Advertise with us

"We hadn't gotten [to deliberating]. We were just venting," said a female juror. "There was just mountains and mountains of evidence. It was just massive."

PG VIDEO: MISTRIAL IN ORIE CASE

"It took so long, we listened to so much -- and we got, what, a day and half to talk about it?" said another male juror who likewise would not identify himself.

"I spent three-and-a-half weeks of my life," said a female juror who declined to be identified. "It was extremely disruptive to my home life.

"We started at 9:30 in the morning and finished at 4:30, but I had to take the bus, and that's another two-and-a-half hours. I spent a lot of time down there away from my family. And to not be able to finish what we started is very frustrating."

Advertise with us

That juror also expressed concern about the court being able to find another 12 jurors who will be impartial after Thursday's events.

Jury foreman Charles King, 30, of the North Side, said he did not envy the task awaiting the next jury in the event of a retrial.

"The next jury will deal with the same thing. ... There was too much doubt over whether it was forged or not," he said. "That was a lot of what we were deliberating on. It was a very hard time deciding on any verdicts -- there was an overwhelming amount of evidence, and it was hard deciding what was truthful and what wasn't."

One of the female jurors also said the experience was additionally frustrating because of the waste of taxpayers' money.

"Part of the whole trial was the theft of services, the cost to the taxpayer," she said. "Well, if that's what the trial is about, then you think about how much it cost to pay all of us, put us up in a hotel, we had really nice dinners. I believe that's a lot of money, too."