Declaring that fraud had been committed, "on the court, the jury and our justice system," Judge Jeffrey A. Manning declared a mistrial Thursday in the corruption case against state Sen. Jane Orie after finding that her defense had submitted forged evidence.
Judge Manning repeatedly excoriated the defense after prosecutors presented evidence that the signature of Jamie Pavlot, Ms. Orie's former chief of staff and a key prosecution witness, had been forged on two documents.
William Costopoulos, the senator's attorney, called the charges outrageous and insisted that there was no evidence that anyone on defense was responsible for the altered documents.
"Your outrage is all well and good, but it does not change the facts here," Judge Manning told the lawyer.
When first confronted with the signatures, a clearly irate Judge Manning rejected Mr. Costopoulos' protest that "these were not doctored."
"Ray Charles could see that signature was doctored," he shot back.
Later, the defense lawyer demanded, "Who did it and why are you blaming us for it?"
No one pointed a finger, but the judge made it clear that he couldn't conceive of an innocent explanation.
After twice noting that he was not accusing Mr. Costopoulos himself of any wrongdoing, he said, "You should look to your own house for the culprit."
"I don't know who among the parties for the defense has done this," Judge Manning said at another point. "It's deceitful, dishonest, despicable, and it's a crime."
PG VIDEO: MISTRIAL IN ORIE CASE
The mistrial came nearly three weeks after the trial started.
The Republican senator and a sister, Janine Orie, are accused of exploiting Senate staffers and resources in campaigns for the senator and for those of another sister, state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin. The charges against the senator extend over nearly a decade.
Janine Orie faced two counts confined to the 2009 high court campaign of Justice Melvin, for whom she had worked as chief aide.
Justice Melvin has not been charged in this case, but a grand jury is reportedly examining her role in the events that brought her sisters' indictment. The justice's lawyer had been a regular presence monitoring the testimony in the sisters' aborted trial.
In statements made before a gag order was imposed on the principals in the case, members of the Orie family had suggested that the charges were the fruit of a political vendetta by Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., a Democrat. His spokesman, Mike Manko, released a terse statement, simply noting the judge's ruling and his finding that "fraud had been perpetrated on the court."
Under Judge Manning's ruling, the senator and Janine Orie now await new trials on the charges -- next time without the tainted evidence.
Mr. Costopoulos, contending that another trial would violate the legal bar against double-jeopardy for his client, said he would appeal the ruling.
During the brief, heated arguments Thursday, Mr. Costopoulos urged that the jurors be allowed to continue their deliberations. He noted that prosecutors had had a chance to challenge the documents during the trial and had, in fact, raised a skeptical question about one of the signatures.
Prosecutor Lawrence Claus countered that the case could continue if the jurors were instructed that some of the evidence before them had been forged. He said that the panel could then decide whether to disregard the issue or conclude that it was evidence of guilty knowledge by the defendants. Mr. Costopoulos violently objected to that option, and Judge Manning said he had no choice but to declare the mistrial. No date was set for a new trial.
Mr. Claus asked that the district attorney's office have continued access to the documents, which had been in the hands of the jury, to review them for evidence of further tampering. Judge Manning said that both sides would continue to have access to the files, but said that in view of the charges, the court would take custody of them pending a new trial.
His mistrial ruling included the charges against Janine Orie as well as the senator. He rejected the argument from Janine Orie's attorney, James DePasquale, that because the documents in question did not directly involve the charges against his client, the jury should be allowed to continue to deliberate on her case.
"The well has been poisoned here and we're not going to drink any more from it," the judge said.
Moments later, after the jury filed back into the courtroom, he dismissed them after apprising them of the fraud.
The startling cascade of events terminating the three-week trial began late in the morning, as prosecutors made an unscheduled appearance in the Manning courtroom. Mr. Claus, the chief prosecutor, presented three documents which showed evidence that the signature of Ms. Pavlot had been cut and pasted from one document to another. Ms. Pavlot was Ms. Orie's top aide in the senator's North Hills office and testified for the prosecution under a grant of immunity.
In a series of rapid-fire exchanges, Mr. Costopoulos, Mr. Claus and the judge discussed the accusations and their potential remedies before Judge Manning ordered the deliberations halted and the documents retrieved from the jury room.
Mr. Claus said that his suspicions about the documents were first piqued by the Pavlot signature on a Sept. 13, 2004, listing of office rules on the letterhead of Jane Orie. The signature on that copy was slightly askew and the final "s" on the word witness, next to the signature, had disappeared. Mr. Claus had pointed out the odd appearance during the trial but stopped short of making any specific accusations about them then.
He said his concern promoted a review of all defense documents submitted at the same time as the Sept. 13 message. The review suggested that the Pavlot signature on a similar Sept. 16, 2004, listing of office regulations had been cut and pasted -- not in the word processing sense of the term, but literally -- onto a Sept. 25, 2006, letter supposedly sent from Ms. Pavlot to the senator.
After the session recessed to allow prosecutors to rustle up a documents expert, the Orie team huddled in the hallway while prosecutors returned to their offices. The courtroom has seldom been more than half-filled through the trial, but by the time of the ensuing midafternoon hearing, it was the toughest ticket on Grant Street. Audience chairs were filled. Other curious observers, including Judges Donna Jo McDaniel and David Cashman, found seats in the jury box for the stunning reality show.
In a subsequent hearing, Mr. Claus presented a handwriting expert, George Papadopoulos, who affirmed that the signatures on both the Sept. 13, 2004, document, and a Sept. 25, 2006, letter, supposedly sent from Ms. Pavlot to Jane Orie, were forgeries.
That letter, a seemingly innocuous message on travel reimbursements, included a handwritten notation from the senator urging her lieutenant to strictly monitor staff travel data.
Those documents were part of a sequence of roughly 50 exhibits introduced late in the trial in the defense questioning of the senator.
Many, like the Sept. 25 letter, included the senator's handwritten instructions to Ms. Pavlot. Those messages were helpful to the defense in that they reinforced their portrayal of Ms. Pavlot as the day-to-day supervisor of the office, and of Ms. Orie as a boss who repeatedly urged her to ensure that political and legislative work were scrupulously separated.
Unlike most of the evidence, which was exchanged by the two sides in pretrial discovery, that collection of papers was not presented until late in the trial and the papers were not available to the prosecution until a few days ago. They represented a significant part of the senator's defense. Mr. Costopoulos had shown them one by one in his cross-examination of Ms. Pavlot. Then, as well as in his final arguments, he mocked the fact that the former chief of staff said she didn't recognize them.
"Never saw it; never saw it," he said ironically as he cited Ms. Pavlot's testimony on the document sequence during his close to the jury.
Some jury members said they sensed something was wrong with the evidence from the Orie team even before the judge notified them of the mistrial, according to jury foreman Charles King. While the prosecution's evidence was time-stamped and official-seeming, much of the Orie evidence appeared photocopied or handwritten.
"There was too much doubt over whether it was forged or not. That was a lot of what we were deliberating. ... There was an overwhelming amount of evidence and it was hard deciding what was truthful and what wasn't," the North Side contractor said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.