Jurors will resume deliberating the charges against Sen. Jane Orie and her sister, Janine Orie, today, weighing three weeks of testimony and dueling metaphors over whether it was prosecution or the defense that was blowing smoke, and just what that smoke was designed to hide.
William Costopoulos, the lawyer for Jane Orie, derided her prosecution as "a smokescreen" and the former chief aide who testified against her as "the biggest smoke bomb" as he asked a jury to acquit the Republican senator of using her public staff and offices as a political resource.
In his closing argument, prosecutor Lawrence Claus said the figurative smoke wafting over the case was sparked by the Ories' conduct and was intended to conceal a nine-year pattern of abuse of the public trust.
James DePasquale, the lawyer for Janine Orie, professed outrage that his client was even in the courtroom.
He argued that the testimony against her was so meager that it didn't merit a response. Mr. DePasquale charged that the commonwealth had decided to indict her because they were seeking "a patsy ... a fall guy" to be charged alongside the senator and he claimed Janine Orie was chosen for that role because "they didn't have the evidence or the courage to indict Justice Joan Orie Melvin [another sister]."
The charges against the senator, including theft of services and conspiracy, extend over a 10-year period and include work on her own campaigns as well as the 2003 and 2009 state Supreme Court races of Justice Melvin. The two counts against Janine Orie focus only on the 2009 high court race. Justice Melvin has not been charged in the case, although a grand jury is reviewing her actions in the 2009 events. Her attorney has been a regular presence in the courtroom monitoring the testimony.
In his 90-minute closing argument, Mr. Costopoulos repeatedly assailed the credibility of the senator's former chief of staff, Jamie Pavlot, who is still employed in Ms. Orie's office. He contended that the 10-count indictment against the prominent Republican "rises and falls on her truthfulness."
He reviewed a series of handwritten messages from the senator to the aide, in which Ms. Orie urged her, in one form or another, to be vigilant in separating political and legislative work. He mocked the fact that Ms. Pavlot had testified that she did not recognize any of those directives.
Pointing to the fact that Ms. Pavlot, like other prosecution witnesses, was testifying under a grant of immunity, he said, "Not only did she cut her deal, she's sitting out in Cranberry making $80,000 plus benefits, doing nothing."
Ms. Pavlot testified that after the investigation of the senator commenced, she was stripped of her title and moved from the senator's district headquarters on McKnight Road to a satellite office in Butler County.
Mr. Costopoulos also turned his scorn on Jennifer Rioja, the former intern whose complaint of seeing political work done in the office in 2009 sparked the investigation.
He called her, "Jennifer Rioja, an intern, Pittsburgh Jen, who was using Senate computers to tout her 'commie, liberal beliefs.' "
Pittsburgh Jen was the signature Ms. Rioja used in to comment on the website Jezebel. In a comment thread unearthed by the defense, she described herself as a "commie liberal" from Pittsburgh.
Much of Mr. Costopoulos' argument focused on inconsistencies between Ms. Pavlot's trial testimony and descriptions of the same events in unsworn interviews with investigators in the early days of the investigation.
The defense lawyer also alluded to political motives in the case.
"We just pretend that this elephant in the courtroom isn't there," he said, noting that the senator's indictment came in an election year.
In his closing arguments, Mr. DePasquale portrayed his client as a peripheral figure, barely involved in the events in the office. He recited a litany of names of witnesses who had never mentioned Janine Orie, who was an aide to Justice Melvin and is accused of helping to direct the use of the senator's staffers for the justice's campaigning.
He explained that Janine Orie did not testify in the trial because the charges "are so insulting and so ridiculous that they do not need a response."
Mr. Claus charged that Jane Orie's use of her public staff from 2001 to 2009 allowed her to create "a well-oiled, well-greased, very effective campaign machine."
Referring to the years when the senator is alleged to have used that staff to abet Justice Melvin's Supreme Court campaigns, he said, "We all know sibling love is great and family love is great ... but you shouldn't help them by misusing [public resources]."
The charges against the senator extend over nearly a decade, but the most vivid and dramatic testimony in this case focused on the days immediately before and after the 2009 November election, when the investigation began and when Ms. Orie and her staff responded with an intense round of e-mailing, texting and sometimes angry face-to-face confrontations. In the defense portrayal, that frenetic activity reflected a scrupulous public servant trying to get to the bottom of events that occurred in an office controlled by Ms. Pavlot. Mr. Claus contended again Wednesday that the sequence showed a panicky official intent on covering up practices that she had known for years to be improper.
He cited a text message from the senator to Ms. Pavlot shortly after she learned that a former intern had resigned and complained to the district attorney's office about political activity in the Senate office.
"Yes Jamie, just be smart and careful, you cannot let your guard down," one message from the senator read in part.
"Is this someone who knows nothing about what was going on?" Mr. Claus asked.
He turned to an e-mail that he also emphasized in his cross-examination of the senator, in which she instructed Ms. Pavlot to find a campaign office for an election that was to take place in just a few days. Mr. Claus depicted that move as an effort to conceal the fact that campaign work had been done in the legislative office.
"She's saying, help me dig my way out of this," he said of the message to the chief of staff.
The seven men and five women on the jury have returned to their homes at the end of each day of the nearly three weeks of testimony, but Judge Manning ordered them sequestered until they reach a verdict.
They deliberated for a little more than two hours Wednesday night before retiring for the evening



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.