State Sen. Jane Orie testified Monday that she never directed staffers to work on campaigns during office hours and had, in fact, repeatedly stressed that any political work had to be on their own time and that it could not be used to earn comp time to offset Senate duties.
Taking the stand in her own defense, the North Hills Republican portrayed Jamie Pavlot, her former chief of staff, as the overseer of all day-to-day operations in her district offices, and said she trusted her "wholeheartedly" to see that her directives were carried out.
The senator's portrait of her relationship with the longtime lieutenant, a key prosecution witness, differed sharply from Ms. Pavlot's. The former chief of staff called the senator a micro-manager steeped in the details of office work including its steady diet of campaign activity. Ms. Orie rejected that characterization, saying that it was Ms. Pavlot who ran the office day-to-day, including during the extended periods in which the senator would be away in Harrisburg.
"She ran the day-to-day operations of the office ... she hired and fired staff," Ms. Orie said.
Describing her 2001 election in which she first won her Senate seat, she said, "Some staff would volunteer after hours ... other than that, they had absolutely nothing to do with my special election."
She insisted that she had been similarly scrupulous in each of her subsequent elections. She identified a series of memos or e-mails in which she had reiterated a policy of separating political work on staff time. The descriptions were in sharp contrast to the testimony of prosecution witnesses, including Ms. Pavlot, who had described an office culture in which campaign chores were a routine part of the work day.
Ms. Orie frequently looked directly at the jury as she described her years in office and tense days that led to the trial.
While Ms. Pavlot had testified that Ms. Orie personally approved comp time for political duties, she said Monday, "I had nothing to do with compiling the comp time records ... on a day-to-day basis, I had no knowledge."
At one point she read her handwritten notation on a 2007 memo from the Senate leadership directing that staffers be trained on ethics guidelines.
"Jamie, you are in charge and must enforce," it said.
"We need to be vigilant about campaign work outside the office," she wrote on another 2007 message to Ms Pavlot introduced by her defense.
"You are in charge -- want rules followed. Please put staff on notice."
Ms. Orie described the day that began this investigation, Oct. 30, 2009, when intern Jennifer Rioja confronted Ms. Pavlot with the news that she was resigning over in-office political activity that she would report to prosecutors.
Ms. Orie also offered her version of the emotional aftermath of the day. She said that Josh Dott, another prosecution witness and former staffer, was driving with her that morning. She said she interrogated him and, "He assured me nothing was wrong."
The senator also disputed a prosecution contention that she had on a later date hidden two political files under her coat in order to spirit them out of the office.
"I never stuck any files under my coat," she insisted.
The senator spoke after more than 50 character witnesses, many of whom traveled to the courthouse from the North Hills on a chartered bus, had vouched for her good reputation.
Eleven character witnesses took the stand to laud the senator's reputation. They included police officers, former prosecutors, a former radio newsman and a retired teacher. After Ms. Orie's attorney, William Costopoulos, set that stage, he turned to a courtroom filled with another 50 or so supporters. They were sworn in en masse and affirmed that they would have echoed the stellar depictions of the Republican's character.
Their testimony followed another defense witness, Kevin Lee Derr, a legislative staff attorney, who worked for the senator in two stints, during the 2003-04 legislative session and again from 2007 to 2008.
Mr. Derr testified that he had never been asked to perform campaign work and that he never observed other staffers doing such work.
Today's testimony is to open with lead prosecutor Lawrence Claus' crucial cross-examination of the senator, who is charged with crimes that span nearly a decade of accusations of mixing state business with politics. On trial with her is her sister Janine Orie, who faces two counts charging that she helped direct the use of the staff for the state Supreme Court campaign of Joan Orie Melvin.
Monday night, Judge Jeffrey Manning said that the testimony could conclude today, which could mean that the jurors would begin their deliberations as early as Wednesday.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.