As her highly anticipated cross-examination opened, state Sen. Jane Orie's former top aide deflected defense suggestions that she'd "cut a deal," to "give the commonwealth the senator," by testifying about political work by the North Hills Republican's legislative staff.
"They told me I needed to tell the truth," Jamie Pavlot insisted as William Costopoulos, Ms. Orie's attorney, pressed her on the negotiations that led to the grant of immunity that has been extended to her and other prosecution witnesses.
"As a named co-conspirator in these crimes, you weren't told you could go to jail?" Mr. Costopoulos asked incredulously as he embarked on the task of casting doubt on Ms. Pavlot's extensive testimony about political activity by the senator's staff.
"They asked me questions about what I knew," Ms. Pavlot said of the district attorney's investigators.
"Who was the target?" Mr. Costopoulos asked.
"They never said there was a target," she replied.
Ms. Pavlot, Ms. Orie's longtime chief of staff, also maintained that no one had suggested to her that she could lose her state pension if she were charged and convicted in this case. But Mr. Costopoulos' initial questioning of the pivotal witness was frustrated by a murky dispute on a series of documents that he asked Ms. Pavlot to identify.
Their contents weren't apparent to the jury or the courtroom and, after the witness said she'd never seen them before, Judge Jeffrey A. Manning ruled that she couldn't be questioned about them.
The exchange came after Lawrence Claus, the chief prosecutor, led Ms. Pavlot through a depiction of panicky improvisation in the days surrounding the 2009 election as the Republican tried to insulate herself from an academic intern's charge that she exploited her state staff for political purposes.
"Oh, you're an early bird today," Ms. Pavlot recalled saying to Jennifer Rioja, the intern who made the complaint, as she encountered her before normal working hours on the Friday before the 2009 election.
The pleasantries didn't last long; Ms. Rioja told her that she was resigning and going to prosecutors to report political activity in the legislative office. Ms. Pavlot said she tried unsuccessfully to dissuade the intern, suggesting to her that she had misinterpreted some of the work around her, that it might have been performed by staffers working on comp time.
Ms. Pavlot said she immediately reported the encounter to Ms. Orie, who ordered her to call University of Pittsburgh Chancellor Mark Nordenberg and two of Ms. Rioja's faculty advisers to insist that no political work was being performed on state time. She said she was able to reach one of the faculty advisers to offer her version of events, but was uncomfortable doing so, "because I knew it was false."
Ms. Pavlot identified an e-mail she received from the senator later that Friday, just four days before the election in which her sister, Justice Joan Orie Melvin, would win a seat on the state Supreme Court.
The subject line was: "Campaign headquarters."
"We need to begin finding one," the body of the message continued.
"Set up desk, etc. Josh [Dott, another staffer and prosecution witness] needs to carry laptop every day once we get headquarters and set up laptop in campaign ... have papers, etc. there."
Ms. Pavlot described returning to the legislative office Sunday, two days later, to prepare a letter to Ms. Rioja and Pitt officials reiterating the denials made in her initial phone conversation.
"At no time has any member of my staff engaged in any political activity during, or on state working time," said the letter, which was sent over the senator's signature.
Ms. Pavlot said she discussed the letter with Mr. Dott, who was assisting her that Sunday, and said, "We thought it was a mistake ... that we were being untruthful."
In another thread of an expanding cover-up described by Ms. Pavlot, she said she wrote a bogus letter to Catholic nuns in an attempt to deceive another intern, Erika Frantz. The previous week, Ms. Frantz had helped in the preparation of a letter that was sent to convents in the region lauding the anti-abortion credentials of Justice Melvin, who was in the last days of the hotly contested Supreme Court race. Ms. Rioja testified earlier that the discovery of her colleagues' work on that letter was the catalyst for her decision to resign and report the political activity.
Ms. Pavlot said that, at the senator's direction, she had a phony letter prepared which purported to be informing the region's convents of legitimate legislative activity. She also prepared small cards with information about the senator as a stand-in for the Melvin poll cards that had been distributed to the nuns. A few days later she displayed the material to the intern.
"I was trying to make her think that she was not working on political activity in the legislative office," she acknowledged.
By then, Ms. Pavlot said, "The senator seemed like she was in a panic."
When Ms. Pavlot informed her that copies of the real poll cards were in a waste basket in an outer office, she said that Ms. Orie ran out, scooped them from the trash, and put them in her pocket.
The staff tried to purge the office of political materials but at one point shortly after the election -- and at the beginning of the investigation that led to these charges -- Ms. Pavlot said she discovered several folders of political material still in her files.
By then, she said, Ms. Orie was convinced -- correctly as it turns out -- that the office was being watched. Ms. Pavlot said the senator put some of the material under her coat, carried it out, and instructed Ms. Pavlot to do the same with the rest.
The senator's anxiety about the probe was also evident in several text messages that she sent to Ms. Pavlot the day after the intern's resignation, voicing her fears about Ms. Rioja and Charlie Young, another staffer who had been friendly with her.
"Tell Kurt and Josh they are to avoid Charlie ... I think Charlie is taping them ... avoid him at all costs ... do not take calls ... stay away," one read.
"Jamie this intern is very aggressive about this ... she has to be a plant ... I am scared Charlie is too," said another.
Ms. Pavlot was Ms. Orie's chief of staff throughout the decade covered by the charges. Nine months ago, she was stripped of her title and reassigned to a satellite office in Cranberry, though she testified that she is still paid her previous salary of roughly $80,000 annually.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.