A former Senate staffer described an office "in frantic mode" the day that a former colleague resigned, charging that state Sen. Jane Orie, R-Mc-Candless, had used her district office and staff to aid her sister's campaign for the state Supreme Court.

Joshua Dott told a jury that he came into the North Hills district office on Oct. 30, 2009, the Friday morning before the 2009 election, shortly after Jennifer Rioja had told Jamie Pavlot, Ms. Orie's chief of staff, that she was resigning.

"I could tell something was wrong," he said. "All Jamie told me was that Jen was quitting and she told her professors."

Ms. Rioja, who had been an academic intern in the office, testified last week that she had voiced her concern over political activity in the office to her faculty advisers the previous day.

Advertise with us

By the time Mr. Dott and Ms. Pavlot were discussing her resignation that Friday, Ms. Rioja was in the process of making a formal complaint to the district attorney's office.

Mr. Dott's testimony demonstrated that investigators acted on the information almost immediately. He said that on the evening of Saturday, Oct. 31, Ms. Pavlot called him and asked him to come into the McKnight Road office the next day to assist her in preparing a letter denying Mr. Rioja's accusations. The letter, signed by Ms. Orie, would be sent to her, to University of Pittsburgh Chancellor Mark Nordenberg and to the two faculty advisers to whom the graduate student had confided.

As they left the office that Sunday, he helped Ms. Pavlot carry boxes to her car. Mr. Dott was not specific about the contents of the boxes, but said they may have contained some personal and some political materials. When they walked out, he said that Ms. Pavlot told him she saw "flashes." He said that at first he doubted her suspicions, but they turned out to be justified. What she had seen was district attorney's investigators taking photographs of the two to them.

In the days immediately following the Rioja resignation, members of the staff exchanged a flurry of e-mails and text messages. In one, Ms. Orie counseled Mr. Dott and another colleague to stay away from Charles Young, a staff member who was a friend of Ms. Rioja.

Mr. Dott told the jury that through the summer and fall of 2009, work on the state Supreme Court campaign of Joan Orie Melvin had assumed more and more of his time. Justice Melvin, then a member of Superior Court, was campaigning as the Republican nominee for the high court seat she would win within a few days of the beginning of the investigation of her sister, who was then the third-ranking Republican in the state Senate.

Advertise with us

One of the day's sharper exchanges took place out of the jury's hearing.

Mr. Dott described a phone call he had received from a district attorney's investigator roughly a week after Ms. Rioja filed her complaint. Mr. Dott said that the agent asked him if he was willing to come in and discuss the case.

"At that point, you were scared," said James DePasquale, the attorney for Janine Orie, the senator's sister, who is also on trial.

"Terrified," Mr. Dott agreed.

The witness went on to describe conversations with his attorney, Charles Porter, on his decision whether to cooperate or resist the investigation. He said that his lawyer had told him that he could fight the prosecution, or, if he did cooperate, it had to be "110 percent."

Advertise with us

Mr. DePasquale started to ask him if he knew who Mr. Porter's law partner had been. With that, Judge Jeffrey Manning immediately ordered the jury out of the courtroom and the attorneys to a conference at the side of his bench. The defense counsel was obviously heading to the point that District Attorney Stephen Zappala Jr. had been a law partner of Mr. Porter before taking public office.

Most of the sidebar conference with Judge Manning and the attorneys was inaudible, but as it broke up, the judge could be heard admonishing, "If you go there, we'll pick another jury."

Mr. Dott said his duties consisted of recording campaign checks and occasionally driving Justice Melvin to campaign events around the state. He estimated that the political work ranged from 5 to 10 percent of his duties earlier in the year, to an average of 25 to 30 percent as the election neared.

While most of this case focuses on Jane Orie, based on accusations that extend over nearly a decade, Janine Orie faces counts of theft of services and conspiracy based on the contention that she directed the senator's staff members to perform work for Justice Melvin's 2009 campaign for the Supreme Court. The prosecution on Monday presented a lengthy list of e-mails in which Janine Orie directed Mr. Dott to perform a variety of chores for the campaign, ranging from recording contributions to distributing lawn signs and literature.

On cross-examination, Mr. DePasquale led Mr. Dott through a painstaking review of the e-mails, challenging him again and again to show any directive to perform the work on state time.

Advertise with us

Drawing out his descriptions of Mr. Dott's volunteer work in other campaigns, Mr. DePasquale sought to portray him as an eager young partisan, happy to devote his own hours to campaigning.

But while conceding that the e-mails did not explicitly demonstrate it, Mr. Dott insisted that his understanding was that he was to do political work on state time and that he had received such instructions from Janine Orie as well as from Ms. Pavlot on the senator's behalf.

Ms. Pavlot, a highly anticipated witness, could take the stand as early as today as the prosecution nears the close of its case.