A former aide to state Sen. Jane Orie said Tuesday that the Republican's staff became more guarded though no less active in performing political chores after former state Rep. Jeff Habay's 2005 conviction for using state resources for his campaigns.
"I got more nervous," said Joseph Smith, a lawyer who worked in Ms. Orie's district offices between 2002 and 2006, the year following the Habay conviction for theft of services and conflict of interest, two of the same charges Ms. Orie is now facing.
"Jamie and I talked about it ... try to be more careful with those activities," Mr. Smith said, referring to Jamie Pavlot, the prosecution witness who was Ms. Orie's chief of staff and, according to earlier witnesses, frequent conduit of instructions on campaign and fundraising activities for the state-paid staff.
Ms. Orie and her sister, Janine Orie, are being tried on charges of using public resources for her campaigns and that of another sister, state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin
Mr. Smith, echoing earlier witnesses for the prosecution, acknowledged that campaign work accounted for a significant part of his day. He said his political tasks ranged from fundraising events to the collection of signatures for nominating petitions for both Jane Orie and for Justice Melvin.
He also said he served as Justice Melvin's chauffeur on campaign trips to Johnstown and Lancaster during her unsuccessful high court race in 2003. Justice Melvin was elected to that bench in 2009, after another campaign that was aided by the work of her sister's staffers, witnesses said.
His testimony followed that of another former staff member who said she had been counseled to disguise the mingling of public and political duties. Christy Folino, an employee from 2001 until 2004, described door-knocking assignments in the North Hills district to pass out political literature and to obtain petition signatures. She said that Ms. Pavlot had advised her and other staffers to say that she was on her own time, if anyone inquired about their workday activities.
"I didn't know it was against the law, what we were doing, ... [but] because we were told to be discreet, I knew it wasn't right," said Ms. Folino, who joined the staff just out of college.
Earlier on the fourth day of the trial, the jury heard two more in what has become a parade of witnesses who have testified both that they did political work on public time and that they were eventually fired from the Orie staff.
Christa Meeder, who worked in the McKnight Road district office, said she spent a significant amount of time in the public office planning or keeping records on fundraising events for the senator.
She said she had received most of her instructions from Ms. Pavlot.
Her most extensive direct encounter with the senator came when Ms. Orie accused her of tampering with the files of a campaign database. Then and now, Ms. Meeder said she denied the accusation, maintaining that there was nothing wrong with the computer file. She said that as a result of the accusation, she decided to copy the database onto a CD, which she took home from the office and later turned over to the prosecution.
On cross-examination, Ms. Orie's attorney, William Costopoulos, accused her of stealing the list.
"I did not steal it," Ms. Meeder insisted, explaining that she wanted to keep copies of the files she was accused of mishandling.
"You knew you weren't supposed to do that, didn't you?" Mr. Costopoulos asked again.
"I didn't do anything wrong," Ms. Meeder said.
Elaine Rickard, who worked in the senator's Cranberry office from 2004 until 2006, when she too was fired, said she had been uncomfortable from the start at the political assignments that came with her job.
Before she left the office, she said, she made a digital copy of a variety of political and fundraising correspondence that flowed through the office. She eventually turned that material over to prosecutors after this investigation began. Asked why she had retained the material, she said, "I felt that what I had was definitely something that a senator from Pennsylvania should not be involved in."
While the testimony so far has included painstaking and often repetitive descriptions of the Orie office practices, most members of the jury have appeared attentive, studying the witnesses, and occasionally taking notes. But the repetition has apparently been too much for the attention span of one of them. Judge Jeffrey A. Manning said he was dismissing juror No. 4 and replacing her with an alternate because she had fallen asleep on each of the four days so far.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.