State Sen. Jane Orie got no valentines from current and former subordinates Monday, as witnesses, one fighting back tears, described a tense office in which state employees were pressured to mix public and political activity.
Kathleen Campbell, who is still employed by the senator, told jurors that she had taken part of one work day to deliver political materials for the campaign of the senator's sister, state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin, to seven convents in the Republican's North Hills district.
On cross-examination, defense lawyers tried to chip away at the prosecution case, as Ms. Campbell, in contrast to earlier witnesses, said political work had represented a relatively insignificant share of her duties -- 30 hours in eight years, by her estimate. But she also suggested that Jane Orie presided over a less-than-nurturing workplace.
Fighting back tears at one point, she said Jamie Pavlot, Jane Orie's chief of staff and another prosecution witness, had, at times, picked on her in the office.
"I did what I was told to keep my job," she said. "Over the years I have been there, I've seen so many people let go. ... I always walked in there with a knot in my stomach."
Asked by William Costopoulos, Jane Orie's attorney, if the senator had been a good employer, she hesitated for a long moment, and said, "Well -- most of the time."
Jane Orie, R-McCandless, is fighting charges, including theft of services and conspiracy, accusing her of using public resources for her campaigns and those of her sister, Justice Melvin, who has not been charged. A third sister, Janine Orie, is on trial with the senator on two counts based on alleged political activity in 2009. Prosecutors contend that Jane Orie presided over a pattern of improper political activity that stretched over the last decade.
Christine Bahr, a retired Orie staffer, told the jury that "nonlegislative as well as legislative work intermingled daily," in the McKnight Road office. Questioned by prosecutor Lawrence Claus, she identified an extensive series of letters, thank-you notes to "heavy hitter" contributors and other political correspondence that she worked on between 1998 and her 2005 retirement. Echoing the testimony of earlier witnesses, she said thestationery for the political letters contained the inscription "Not paid for at taxpayers' expense."
Asked if that assertion were true, she said: "Not really. It was done on state time, and I guess the taxpayers paid for some of it in many ways."
She described herself as an admirer of the senator and her work, but she also related examples of sharp treatment of the office staff.
"She would get so angry at times," she said of Jane Orie. "It was almost demeaning, which I didn't like."
Defense attorneys objected to the repeated focus on Jane Orie's demeanor. Judge Jeffrey A. Manning halted testimony and sent the jury out while he admonished the attorneys, particularly the prosecution, that the testimony about Ms. Orie's behavior was irrelevant to the charges.
"This trial is not about whether Sen. Orie has a temper," he said.
Earlier, Ms. Bahr had testified that normally 20 to 30 percent of her work was political, and that the proportion of nonlegislative work jumped to roughly 40 percent in the days preceding the senator's annual fundraiser. In addition to the correspondence that formed a large part of her duties, Ms. Bahr said she and other staffers were occasionally dispatched to a nearby office to make calls to constituents in which they were instructed to pretend to be Jane Orie.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.