The Allegheny County district attorney's office has asked the state Supreme Court to reject Republican pleas that the justices to throw out key charges in the case in which GOP colleague state Sen. Jane Orie is charged with using state resources to promote the Supreme Court candidacy of her sister.
The prosecution dismissed the McCandless Republican's contentions that a conflict of interest charge based on the state ethics law is unconstitutionally vague. The office also rebuts an argument that a search of Ms. Orie's Senate office and computers violated the separation of powers doctrine that protects lawmakers from arrest for actions taken during the normal course of their duties.
Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning has rejected similar arguments made by the Orie side in the case, in which jury selection is scheduled to begin Tuesday.
The prominent Republican is charged with 10 separate counts related to the overall allegation that she used her state-paid staff to campaign for Justice Joan Orie Melvin's successful bid for a seat on the state high court -- the same bench now being asked to take extraordinary jurisdiction in this case. Their sister, Janine Orie, an assistant in the senator's office, faces three counts in the case.
Prosecutors reiterated their argument that the conflict of interest count is not impermissibly vague, a position that they note was upheld when a similar appeal arose in the prosecution of former Rep. Jeff Habay, who was convicted and jailed for using his staff for political purposes. They point out in the answer to the appeal that Ms. Orie, in fact, voted for the Ethics Law that contains the provision in question when she was a member of the state House.
They also urged the court to reject the claim that the state constitution's speech and debate clause should have protected Ms. Orie from the search of her North Hills offices. They argue that the provision does not apply to the search as it involved actions that were not related to Ms. Orie's official duties as a member of the Legislature.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.