HARRISBURG -- For a time, at least, Monday's debate on the floor of the state House gave the impression that the Democratic minority and the Republican majority had kissed and made up.

Gone were the histrionics and outbursts that earned them some unwanted attention and headlines last week.

Instead, the House in calm and mostly civil terms debated a quintet of bills aimed at shielding whistle-blowers, closing "revolving doors," and otherwise making Pennsylvania government more accountable and transparent.

But no sooner had they given preliminary approval to those bills than the grumbling resumed.

Advertise with us

House Democrats, who last week decried a GOP attempt to make it harder for them to amend bills, claimed that Republicans had simply resorted to another tactic to keep them a silent minority.

"Today was another example of clever parliamentary maneuvers," Bill Patton, spokesman for the House Democratic caucus, said of Monday's debate.

During that debate, Republicans abandoned efforts to pass the rules changes that had sparked Democrats' ire last week. Those changes would have barred members from making amendments to bills on the floor. Thus on Monday, Democrats tried to amend the reform bills -- which, all sides appear to agree, are good measures.

But on most of the amendments, Republicans were able to shut down debate by voting that they were not "germane" to the original bills.

The House's new majority leader, Mike Turzai, R-Bradford Woods, defended the move, saying that the majority of the chamber gets to decide the "germaneness" of an amendment. And the majority, he added, deemed the amendments Democrats were trying to advance were, well, not germane.

Advertise with us

The squabbling over rules and reform is in part the fruits of the fall elections, in which Republicans, many of them running as reformers, undid Democrats' slim majority and now hold a durable 112-91 edge in the House.

"Today, we moved forward on a substantive agenda," Mr. Turzai said. "I think you are going to see we are going to maintain an approach that is responsible and civil ... and I think everyone understands that you cannot be gunslingers about filing amendments as a way to stop a substantive agenda."

Last week, Mr. Turzai and other top Republicans had accused their Democratic counterparts of filing a slew of amendments intended to gum up passage of the reform bills. The GOP response was to propose overturning internal House rules so that amendments could be tabled without tabling the underlying bill -- a move that would have effectively allowed them to muzzle the minority party.

A committee hearing on the issue last week devolved into shouting ("You should be ashamed!" some Democrats cried), with some lawmakers tossing papers in the air and others storming out.

Republicans on Monday decided to abandon the rules changes that had so angered Democrats. But the GOP side gave few details as to what had changed its thinking.

Advertise with us

The reform bills at issue would extend whistle-blower protections to state contractors' employees as well as to workers on state payrolls; would toughen revolving-door rules to bar state officials from evaluating contract proposals submitted by companies they recently worked for; and would expand what people can learn about state procurement contracts.

Another bill would put into the Legislative Code of Ethics a ban on lawmakers creating or maintaining nonprofit entities that receive public funds, a prohibition that already exists under House rules.

The reform measures could come up for final House passage as soon as next week. They still face action in the GOP-controlled state Senate.