HARRISBURG -- Several dozen House Democrats, in a rare move, publicly assailed their top three leaders Monday over a decision not to hold any more voting sessions this year.

The unhappy rank-and-file members complained that the move will kill 15 worthwhile bills that are on the verge of final approval, including one to ease a growing pension crisis for state government and school districts.

Even though Speaker Keith McCall, Majority Leader Todd Eachus and Appropriations Chairman Dwight Evans have ruled out any more voting days before the current session ends Nov. 30, at least 70 House members showed up on the House floor anyway Monday, 50 or more Democrats and at least 20 Republicans. They insisted they are ready to vote on some important measures if House leaders would just convene a session.

The leaders' decision to cancel all additional voting is "unjust, unacceptable and unbelievable. I'm disgusted," said Rep. Robert Matzie, D-Beaver. "We deserve an opportunity to vote yes or no on the pension bill."

Advertise with us

"It's the fourth quarter and we have the football on the one-yard line, and yet we're walking away from the line of scrimmage," complained Rep. Bill Kortz, D-Dravosburg. "Let's get back to session and get our work done."

"I'm very disappointed with our leaders," said Rep. Nick Kotik, D-Robinson. "I urge Speaker McCall, Majority Leader Eachus and Chairman Evans to bring us back into session so we can vote on these bills."

But there isn't much that can be done against two of them, since Mr. McCall is retiring Nov. 30. Mr. Eachus, who lost his re-election bid last Tuesday, also leaves that day.

Mr. Evans, a powerful Philadelphia legislator, has great sway with many legislators due to taxpayer-funded grants he doles out to his political allies, especially those from Philadelphia, said Rep. Tom Caltagirone, D-Berks, House Judiciary Committee chairman.

"I think Mr. Evans has to go" as Appropriations chairman, Mr. Caltagirone said. "That's my own personal opinion." Other House Democrats said they might challenge Mr. Evans next week for his influential post.

Advertise with us

The three Democratic leaders were also assailed by union leaders. James Testerman of the Pennsylvania State Education Association, a large teachers union, urged the House to return and vote on the pension bill. Without action, he said, pension costs are set to skyrocket for state government and the 500 school districts.

"If the House does not address this issue before the legislative session ends this month," he said, "school districts will be staring at double-digit increases in their pension contributions and facing pressure to increase property taxes."

Gabe Morgan, an official of another major union, the Service Employees International Union, said taxpayers "cannot afford to have the state House quit early this year."

Neither Mr. McCall, Mr. Eachus nor Mr. Evans attended the informal House session Monday or have said much about why they decided to scrap further voting sessions.

Some Democratic leaders opposed the decision to ban further votes, including House Whip Frank Dermody of Oakmont, Rep. Joe Markosek of Monroeville (Transportation Committee chairman) and Rep. Tony DeLuca of Penn Hills (Insurance Committee chairman).

Advertise with us

Mr. McCall and Mr. Eachus have been unavailable for comment to reporters. But on Monday, Mr. Caltagirone said he had talked to Mr. McCall, who indicated that Mr. Evans was the reason for not holding any more votes.

On Friday, Mr. Evans said the pension reform bill, House Bill 2497, shouldn't be voted on because the Republican-controlled Senate attached what Mr. Evans called an unconstitutional amendment to it. The amendment would create an "independent fiscal office" for the Legislature, which Mr. Evans said would unnecessarily add $4 million to the cost of state government.

The pension bill, which Mr. Evans had originally drafted in June, was intended to decrease a huge "spike" in pension costs that state government and school districts will be faced with by mid-2012, a spike that could increase taxes. The bill wouldn't affect benefits for current state and school district retirees, but would lower pension benefits for newly hired workers.

Even if no action is taken on the pension bill, the House Democrats said there are lots of other important bills to vote on and send to Gov. Ed Rendell for signature. These include bills to encourage farmers to donate excess products to food banks; a bill for a one-year delay in a requirement that new single-family houses have sprinkler systems; a bill to promote wind power; and a bill to create a statewide electronic waste recycling program.

And still another bill would expand the "Castle Doctrine," allowing a homeowner to use deadly force against an intruder who is found in his garage, front yard or driveway. Currently the homeowner must "retreat" from the intruder before using a firearm.

Advertise with us

"Allowing these bills to die from inaction would be unwise," said Rep. Mark Longietti, D-Mercer. "It would deprive Pennsylvanians from immediate benefits."

"I was appalled when I heard there wouldn't be a voting session Monday," said Rep. Barbara McIlvaine-Smith of Chester County. "My disappointment was so huge."

November is the Democrats' last gasp as House leaders, because Republicans will take control in January when the 2011-12 Legislature opens.