Butler car dealer Mike Kelly swept incumbent Erie Democrat Kathy Dahlkemper out of Congress, joining the wave of Republicans across the state and nation going to the Capitol.

Ms. Dahlkemper joined moderate Democrats Patrick Murphy and Chris Carney, from the eastern part of the state, in getting bounced by Republicans Tuesday. Meanwhile, fellow freshman Democrat Mark Critz of Johnstown, elected in a special election in May, won a tight race in the state's 12th District.

McCandless Democrat Jason Altmire won a surprisingly close race against Republican challenger Keith Rothfus, making him one of only two "Blue Dog" Pennsylvania Democrats to win re-election, along with Schuylkill County's Tim Holden.

"Tonight, voters across the country have sent a message that they are looking for men and women to go to Washington to fix the economy and practice fiscal responsibility," said Mr. Kelly, a gregarious Cadillac and Hyundai dealer who put much of his own money into the campaign, but was still outspent by the freshman Democrat. "It's what the voters of the 3rd District have demanded and deserve. I will not let them down."

Advertise with us

Incumbents Mike Doyle, D-Forest Hills, and Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair, were easily re-elected.

With the exception of Mr. Doyle's 14th District, every Western Pennsylvania congressional district voted for John McCain over Barack Obama for president in 2008, making them ripe for national attention from Republicans this anti-Washington election year.

In the 4th District, Mr. Altmire had a huge financial advantage over Mr. Rothfus, a tireless worker who proved himself against the much better-known Mary Beth Buchanan in the GOP primary in May. Early on, the incumbent -- who entered office with the Democratic wave of 2006 -- distanced himself from Democrats, Mr. Obama and the health care and cap-and-trade energy bills the president supported. That record (and Mr. Altmire's willingness to exploit it) also hurt Mr. Rothfus as he tried to distance himself from the conservative Democrat, as they had the same positions on many issues.

Many labor groups saw a difference between them, however, in the end endorsing Mr. Altmire for re-election even after heaping heavy criticism on the Democrat after his vote against health care reform.

Labor also came to the aid of Ms. Dahlkemper, an Erie freshman who beat seven-time GOP incumbent Phil English in 2008. Both she and Mr. English are moderates, unlike Mr. Kelly, who hewed the conservative line on cutting taxes and entitlements -- and trying to appeal health care reform -- and won a tough, six-way GOP primary in the spring. His message continued into the fall, battering Ms. Dahlkemper on the health care bill, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and abortion rights.

Advertise with us

Ms. Dahlkemper was a late vote in favor of the health care bill, co-authoring a popular provision allowing young adults to stay on their parents' insurance into their mid-20s. But the vote incensed anti-abortion groups, who claim the bill allows for federal funding of the procedure. The anti-abortion congresswoman disputed that, but it did nothing to stop the rain of attack ads from outside the district.

For almost 50 years, through many changes in congressional district lines, there has been only one person to represent northwest Pennsylvania who was not from Erie, its biggest city. That was Mercer County's Marc Marks, who represented the area from 1977-82.

Ms. Dahlkemper issued a statement wishing Mr. Kelly her best and saying, "I am proud of my record in Congress. I delivered on the promises I made on the campaign trail: to reform the health care system, take on the fiscal irresponsibility in Washington and strengthen the economy of Western Pennsylvania."

Mr. Critz was a little-known district director to the late Congressman John Murtha before he won the Democratic Party's nod in the special election to fill his boss' 12th District seat in May. National money poured into the race on his behalf and for Republican Tim Burns, as the race was seen as an early test of disaffection toward the Obama administration. So it was a bit of surprise when Mr. Critz handily won their first race.

That took some of the national luster off the pair's rematch Tuesday. So did the fact that the GOP had little to criticize Mr. Critz about, other than the "D" next to his name, since in his few months in office he did not have to take possibly damaging votes on energy legislation and other matters. Mr. Burns still ran much closer to Mr. Murtha's former aide than he did in May, riding Republican resentment that built throughout the year.

Advertise with us

Tim Murphy, a four-term incumbent, is a psychologist and co-chair of the GOP's House doctor's caucus, and a strong voice against the health care bill. He has long survived the oddly shaped district across parts of Allegheny, Washington and Westmoreland counties despite a Democratic registration edge, and never faced a close race.

The Democrat vying to change that was Dan Connolly, an attorney and former Senate Judiciary Committee aide from South Park. He gained labor support and brought in well-known Democratic names such as Patricia Schroeder in an attempt to raise his local profile, but faced the money troubles well-known to those taking on an entrenched incumbent: he had $64,000 in his campaign account going into October to Mr. Murphy's $897,000.

Mike Doyle has never been in danger of losing his Democrat-dominated 14th District, and had not faced a Republican challenger since 2002, when he still represented the former 18th District. This year he faced Western Pennsylvania's only bona fide tea party candidate, Republican Melissa Haluszczak, a Coraopolis paralegal. He also faced Green Party candidate Ed Bortz.