Wary of potential loopholes under the new health care law, two state senators have introduced separate bills to ensure no taxpayer money will be used to fund abortions, prompting condemnation from abortion rights groups, who said that one bill, in particular, would severely restrict access to the procedure.
While it's too late for the measures -- introduced last month by Sens. Don White, R-Indiana, and Jane Orie, R-McCandless -- to be acted upon this year, both plan to bring them back in the next legislative session. That would prompt yet another battle on an issue that remains unsettled here and across the country long after a 1992 U.S. Supreme Court decision declared the Pennsylvania Abortion Control Act the law of the land.
Pennsylvanians for Choice, a statewide coalition of abortion rights groups, claimed Mr. White's bill would severely restrict access to abortion under the new health care law by banning private insurers who contract with state-run "exchanges" going into effect in 2014, from covering the elective procedure.
Currently, most private health care plans cover abortion, but under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, individuals without access to employer-based health plans -- self-insured, small businesses, the unemployed -- will be required to purchase private health care through the state-run exchanges.
"Today, most private insurance plans cover abortion care," said Susan Frietsche, senior staff attorney at the Women's Law Project. "Senator White's proposal would leave women worse off than they were before health care reform began."
Abortion rights groups also objected to language in the bill, which they said penalized rape and incest victims, even as a spokesman for Mr. White said the senator planned to leave the language out next year.
Under his proposal, rape victims who obtain health insurance through a state-run health care exchange would have been required to report the crimes within 72 hours to receive insurance coverage for an abortion.
It also required incest victims to report the crime within 72 hours of being notified by a doctor of a pregnancy before receiving state exchange insurance coverage for an abortion.
Such "insulting and burdensome" rape reporting requirements in Medicaid coverage were struck down by Commonwealth Court in 1984, Ms. Frietsche said.
She called Mr. White's bill "a throwback to the days when society blamed rape victims for somehow being responsible for the violence that was done to them."
"If the folks from the Pennsylvania coalition contacted us, they would have understood that when you introduce a bill, that is by no means a final product," said Mr. White's chief of staff, Joe Pittman, noting that the language was included "for the purposes of beginning the process."
Additionally, under Mr. White's bill, health insurers participating in the state-run exchanges would have been only able to provide abortion coverage in cases where the pregnancy was caused by rape or incest, or "to avert the death of a mother due to a physical disorder, physical illness or physical injury."
That's a narrower definition of medical necessity than the current Pennsylvania law, which allows abortion when a physician believes that it is "necessary" based on "all factors (physical, emotional, psychological, familial and the woman's age) relevant to the well-being of the woman."
Mr. White will rephrase the definition of medical necessity in his bill next year to reflect current state law, Mr. Pittman said.
The senator's main objective, he added, was "to make restrictions under the health care exchange consistent with those in place with any other taxpaper-funded insurance program."
The first of Ms. Orie's two bills would reaffirm the ban on taxpaper-funded abortions under the new health care law, she said.
"While the Insurance Department's plan states that elective abortions are not covered, there is a concern that the term 'elective abortion' is too loose and might be construed to cover any abortion procedure," Ms. Orie said.
Her second bill would require a female under age 18 seeking court approval of an abortion -- called a judicial bypass because it allows a judge to sign off on the procedure, bypassing a parent -- to have her court petition notarized.
Such requirements have been struck down by courts in the past, noted Ms. Frietsche, adding that privacy issues are a concern.
"This bill would add yet another barrier to young women's access to this legal medical procedure and potentially exposes their names to public view in a notary's log," Ms. Frietsche said.
The bill also would require the state Department of Health to issue an annual report listing the number of court-approved abortions for minors. Currently, the Department of Health publishes an annual report but does not list the number of judicial bypasses.
"We really have no idea in Pennsylvania whether a judge signing off on an abortion is doing it once or a thousand times, and it's important information people should have," said Charlene Bashore, legislative director of the Pennsylvania Pro-Life Federation.
She also discounted claims that the bills would significantly restrict access to abortions under state-run health care exchanges.
"The real headline here should be, women can have an abortion, they just have to pay for it themselves," Ms. Bashore said, noting that women will be able to purchase separate insurance riders covering abortion.
Such insurance coverage may be hard to come by, abortion rights groups countered, noting that women rarely plan for abortions in advance and might be reluctant to buy separate coverage up front -- prompting insurers to stop offering it.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.