The Nov. 2 rematch between freshman Congressman Mark Critz and his Republican rival Tim Burns is a relative snooze compared to the frantic special election that six months ago focused national attention on the question of who would succeed the late powerhouse John P. Murtha.

Mr. Critz, former economic development director for Mr. Murtha, comfortably bested Mr. Burns in the May special election -- held on the same ballot that gave each man his party's nomination for the November general election for a full term.

Since then, Mr. Critz has ensconced himself among fellow Democrats in the House while Mr. Burns, a self-made millionaire, has worked to regroup his forces for another try. Six months ago, the contest for the 12th Congressional District was heavily polled, watched keenly for hints of the Obama administration's legislative future, and the focus of millions of dollars in outside advertising.

Pollsters have described the contest as "leaning" toward the Democrats, but Mr. Burns and his campaign strategist, Kent Gates, argue that an estimated 80,000 independent voters, locked out of the May primary and less likely to turn out for the special, could swing Republican.

Advertise with us

"I was polling pretty well with independents, but the independents didn't come out," Mr. Burns said. Additionally, Republican analysts also argued that an intense Democratic primary fight between Sen. Arlen Specter and his in-party challenger Joe Sestak pumped up the numbers for Mr. Critz.

The 12th is a sprawling district that reaches from the West Virginia border in Greene County, crosses through Washington, Fayette and Armstrong counties into parts of Cambria, Somerset and Indiana. The voters there are traditionalists, socially conservative with a large segment still drawn by the legacy of organized labor.

Mindful of this, Mr. Critz has put up a series of spots that show him walking through a steel mill in Johnstown and ending with the message that he is "pro-life and pro-gun."

The Burns camp has unveiled its own series of ads adding another thing they say Mr. Critz is: pro-Pelosi.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., is a recurring theme in the Republican narrative this year and Mr. Burns says the Critz commercials are an effort to distract from his voting record.

Advertise with us

Depending on which side is talking, Mr. Critz has either voted 98 percent of the time with Mrs. Pelosi or 58 percent of the time with Republican leader John Boehner.

"You can almost make the numbers say what you want them to. They're saying I vote with the Democrats most of the time. I'm a Democrat. That stands to reason," Mr. Critz said.

Voters in the 12th, he said, "want to know what you're going to do locally. They don't care about Nancy Pelosi."

Mr. Burns said while he is counting on a new band of voters from which to draw Nov. 2, he's still committed to his earlier campaign themes: "Stop the stimulus package that didn't work, and repeal Health Care Reform that's going to kill jobs."

Mr. Critz, who was not in Congress at the time those bills passed, has said he would have opposed the health care reform bill as it passed but is now committed to improving the legislation now on the books.