HARRISBURG -- President Barack Obama's unpopularity, the retirement of the longtime Democratic leader and four open seats -- all in Democratic districts -- could put the state Senate even more firmly in the hands of Republicans on Election Day.
On the other hand, some say that Senate Democrats could become more relevant in the next legislative term, even with fewer seats.
Minority Leader Robert Mellow has been the voice of the caucus since 1989. However, his words have carried so little weight that Steve Crawford, Gov. Ed Rendell's chief of staff, once referred to the caucus as the Senate Ladies Auxiliary, a term that's stuck.
Republicans control the Senate, 30-19, with one seat open after the midterm departure of Sean Logan, D-Monroeville.
Now Senate Democrats have a chance to raise their profile, said Chris Borick, professor of political science at Muhlenberg College. They'll install a new leader who could end up forging compromises between House and Senate Republicans, who are often at odds.
That could be amplified if the House goes into Republican hands and if Republican Tom Corbett becomes governor.
"In a situation where one party has ownership of everything, you really start looking for the minority voice," Mr. Borick said.
Now, with a Democratic governor and House, Senate Republicans provide that minority voice at leadership meetings, said Tom Baldino, professor of political science at Wilkes University. If there are more Republicans at the negotiating table, Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati of Jefferson and Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi of Delaware County could fade, he said.
Senate Democrats will be looking to bring a strong, energetic, confident leader into the mix.
One contender for that role could be Sen. Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, who now is ranking Democrat on the powerful Appropriations Committee.
Mr. Mellow, D-Lackawanna, is retiring along with Raphael Musto, D-Luzerne, and Barry Stout, D-Bentleyville. Those seats and Mr. Logan's have been so secure that except in one case, Republicans put up no challengers.
The exception was 2002, when Old Forge businessman Frank Scavo challenged Mr. Mellow but got just 39 percent of the vote.
Eight years later, Mr. Scavo is back, this time facing Archbald native John Blake, who served as executive director of the Lackawanna County Redevelopment Authority and, later, as director of Mr. Rendell's northeast Pennsylvania office.
Voters in Mr. Logan's, Mr. Musto's and Mr. Stout's districts will, for the first time in at least two election cycles, have real choices to make in the Senate general election.
Candidates in those races are:
• For Mr. Logan's seat, Democratic McKeesport Mayor Jim Brewster and Republican Paul Olijar, a former Plum school director.
• For Mr. Musto's seat, Democratic state Rep. John Yudichak, D-Luzerne, and Luzerne County Commissioner Stephen A. Urban.
• For Mr. Stout's seat, Democratic state Rep. Tim Solobay, D-Canonsburg, and Republican Kris Vanderman, a Charleroi attorney and cattle rancher.
Those districts are Democratic strongholds, but if Republicans want to flip them, the time is now, when seats are open.
Incumbents have so many advantages -- name recognition, records of success, political experience and support systems -- that party leaders seldom invest time, money and energy to challenge them, Mr. Baldino said.
Locally, for example, Republicans fielded no candidates to run against veteran Democratic senators Richard Kasunic of Dunbar, Wayne Fontana of Brookline or Jim Ferlo of Highland Park.
One incumbent who isn't taking re-election for granted is Sen. Jane Orie. R-McCandless.
Ms. Orie, a longtime part of the Republican establishment, is vulnerable because of her arrest this year on charges that she directed state employees who worked on the appellate court campaign of her sister, Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin.
Without those charges, Ms. Orie would have cruised into another term unopposed.
However, spurred by news of the investigation that led to those charges, Democrats put up Ross Commissioner Dan DeMarco.
Anti-Obama sentiment could help Ms. Orie and other Republicans at the polls, pundits said, but the biggest factor will be voter turnout, which is often low for midterm elections.
"Obama is a liability for every Democrat running because of his low popularity," Mr. Baldino said.
Even college students, who helped propel Mr. Obama to the White House, are increasingly unhappy with his job performance.
According to a recent Associated Press-mtvU poll, 44 percent of college students approve of the job the president is doing. That's down from 60 percent in May 2009.
Heads in the Game
One in a series about concussions and brain injuries in young football players.
Sunday: The story of one Western Pennsylvania youth who died from a brain injury while playing football.
Today: New treatments for local athletes with lingering concussions.
Go to post-gazette.com to read previous stories in the series
Heads in the Game
One in a series about concussions and brain injuries in young football players.
Sunday: The story of one Western Pennsylvania youth who died from a brain injury while playing football.
Today: New treatments for local athletes with lingering concussions.
Go to post-gazette.com to read previous stories in the series



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.