For Dan Onorato, the contest for governor started out as an away game.
Rather than following the traditional stagecraft of a hometown announcement surrounded by relatives and supporters, Mr. Onorato traveled to the opposite corner of the state. He made his official debut as a candidate in an ornate reception room in Philadelphia's City Hall. He flew back across the state before repeating his announcement speech in front of a crowd that knew how to pronounce his name.
Seven years earlier, when the Brighton Heights lawyer kicked off his announcement for county executive, Gov. Ed Rendell came to Pittsburgh to stand by his side. The two announcements point to some of the strengths and challenges surrounding Mr. Onorato's bid to become the first Democratic governor from his hometown since David L. Lawrence.
Mr. Onorato's debut trip to Philadelphia, while slightly unorthodox, made perfect sense. The city remains, as it has been since the 1950s, the state's largest Democratic stronghold. And over the past two decades, its suburbs have become more populous and more Democratic, to the point that those bedroom communities can claim to be the new center of gravity for Democratic politics.
Mr. Onorato's initial schedule signaled his need to become better known in that vote-rich corner of the state. The quirky ad in which he reminds statewide voters how to say his name shows that that challenge continues.
Like Mr. Lawrence and Mr. Rendell, Mr. Onorato hoped to win votes across the state projecting the image of a pragmatist who worked with business to restore his hometown's economy. But in a race that began just as the world economy was spiraling downward, polls suggest that message has had a tough time breaking through.
Mr. Onorato was trained as a lawyer and an accountant. He was brought up in a family that was involved in the community but not overtly political. His mother was a teacher at a Catholic school; his father, a mechanic at Allis Chalmers Co., "coached Little League for decades."
It was a close Italian family. His paternal grandfather was an immigrant. His mother's roots were just one more generation removed from Italy.
"We always talked about things that were happening in the world, the region and the neighborhood, and they were very civic minded," Mr. Onorato recalled. "I took it the next step further and decided to run for office and represent people in the political realm."
Mr. Onorato went to North Catholic High School. He was two years ahead of Jim Burn, now the state Democratic chairman. A half generation later, the Troy Hill school would produce another now-prominent Democrat, Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl.
Mr. Onorato spent part of Oct. 9 campaigning among the tailgaters at Penn State University, where he earned his degree in accounting in 1983. He became a certified public accountant with the firm Grant Thornton and after a few years went on to the University of Pittsburgh's Law School.
While at Pitt, he met his wife, Shelly. She would give birth to Kate, the first of their three children, in 1991. Mr. Onorato's political ambitions were gestating at the same time, as he decided to challenge a City Council incumbent, Bernard "Baldy" Regan.
Relying on his own and his family's community connections, his low-budget campaign wrested the Democratic nomination from Mr. Regan in a close race, with just more than 51 percent of the vote.
He displayed a combative streak in council debates, although most of the colleagues with whom he clashed ended up supporting him in subsequent elections.
In 1994, while he was still in his first term on council, a state Senate seat unexpectedly opened up with the death of Sen. Gene Scanlon.
In the only political loss he's faced so far, he ended up trailing Jack Wagner, then a fellow councilman, in a four-way race. Mr. Wagner, now the state's auditor general, this year was one of the three Democrats he defeated to win the nomination for governor.
After easily winning a second council term, he ran a successful campaign for Allegheny County controller, then four years later ousted Republican Jim Roddey to take over the county's top job.
Just five months into his tenure, he was confronted with a budget gap. He quickly addressed it with the announcement that he would cut 500 county jobs, many of them in the jurisdiction of the unions that had backed him against the Republican.
At the same time, he was dealing with the slow-motion departure of US Airways from Pittsburgh International Airport. Once the airline had been an employment beacon for the region, promising to replace the jobs of the faded steel industry. Now the airline's Pittsburgh presence seemed to be going the same way as steel.
Overall, the Pittsburgh region hardly seemed a candidate for a feel-good economic story. But obscured by the airline woes was the fact that the region's economy had been diversifying for years with a different employment profile strengthened by the city's educational and medical resources.
By the time Mr. Onorato won a second term over token opposition, the Pittsburgh region's unemployment rate had dipped below the national level for the first time in decades. Mr. Onorato couldn't take personal credit for the transformation, but he encouraged it by working to attract state and federal money to rehabilitate brownfields -- old industrial sites. And he continued to preside over a balanced county budget.
As Mr. Onorato joined President Barack Obama and the leaders of the Group of 20 nations at a Phipps Conservatory and Botanical Gardens gala in September 2009, Pittsburgh had assumed the unexpected role as poster child for urban transformation.
Mr. Onorato would rest a big part of his campaign message on that regional shift. And it remains true that the Pittsburgh region has a lower jobless rate than the state or the nation. But amid rising unemployment across the state, a sunny economic message was harder to sell to an increasingly angry electorate.
Mr. Onorato has run a more visible retail campaign than his opponent. But as they compete to run against the excesses of Harrisburg, the attorney general has had the key advantage of the months of headlines generated by prosecutions of legislative abuses. Mr. Onorato has been frustrated in trying to engage his opponent's relatively low-key campaign.
"I have press conferences every week, talk to reporters all the time; when's the last time he had a new conference?" he complained last week.
Mr. Onorato had an opportunity to draw out his opponent in a debate Saturday night, and he has another chance this week in Philadelphia.
In their first general election encounter this month in Hershey, Mr. Onorato displayed his differences with the Shaler Republican. While both cast themselves as fiscal conservatives, among the issues on which they disagree are the wisdom of a severance tax on the burgeoning natural gas industry and the need to increase state funding for basic education.
Mr. Corbett, who has received the lion's share of the gas industry's political contributions in the race, calls the proposal a job-killer. Mr. Onorato argues that virtually every other gas-producing state has such a levy, and that its revenue is needed to deal with the environmental consequences of the new industry.
Mr. Corbett has said the state can't afford to consider more education funding at a point when its budget faces multibillion-dollar shortfalls for transportation and pension costs.
Mr. Onorato has not specified how far the state can go in the near term on bolstering its aid to school districts, but he argues that Mr. Corbett's hold-the-line views are a prescription for tax increases at the local level.
"My opponent wants to push it down and tell the school districts, 'you handle it.' " he said. "That's not good public policy."
While the Democrat boasts of his record of holding the line on property taxes, the Corbett campaign has attacked him over the fact that he persuaded County Council to fund transit with a tax on car rentals and drinks in bars and restaurants. Mr. Onorato said rather than create new taxes, he had lobbied for the transfer of a portion of the revenue from the Regional Asset District's sales tax.
But given that the Legislature blocked that option, he said the drink tax, first 10 percent, now reduced to 7 percent, was a better option than an increase in property taxes.
Mr. Onorato depicts himself as the true Harrisburg outsider in the race. He's called for a state constitutional convention to consider reform proposals, including a smaller Legislature, and a bipartisan commission to take congressional redistricting out of politics.
In a tough year for Democrats up and down the ballot, Mr. Onorato insists that the race is "a statistical tie in a number of polls," an analysis that suggests some creativity in his accounting skills. The latest polling average compiled by website Pollster.com finds Mr. Corbett with an average lead of 49.9 percent to 39.1 percent.
"I've never thought about what I would do if I didn't win any of my races, and I'm not going to do that now," he said. "I really believe we are going to win ... We have the momentum; my opponent is losing momentum. We're ready to bring this thing home."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.