In the North Hills' 40th state Senate District, a Democratic challenger is trying to exploit the dynamics aiding Republican candidates across the country.
Amid a deep and stubborn recession, polls show the GOP as the beneficiary of anger at the political establishment. In Pennsylvania, the reaction against the status quo has battered the approval ratings of a president elected in a landslide two years ago and a Democratic governor re-elected with ease two years earlier. That tanking popularity adds to the challenges facing Democratic candidates up and down the ballot.
But with a late-starting campaign, Ross Commissioner Dan DeMarco hopes to forge an upset by making a Republican incumbent, state Sen. Jane Orie, a symbol of the political establishment. While both candidates cite a variety of issues in the race, it wouldn't even exist without one of them -- the incumbent's indictment on charges of using public staff and resources to aid the appellate court campaign of her sister, Supreme Justice Joan Orie Melvin.
Until the news broke that a grand jury was investigating the senator, Democrats hadn't even bothered to field a candidate against her. With that opportunity, Mr. DeMarco, now in his 11th year as a Ross commissioner, mounted a last minute write-in bid for the Democratic nomination.
Ms. Orie, who has been successful at attracting Democratic support in previous elections, tried to head him off at that pass by launching her own write-in effort to capture the Democratic standard along with the nomination of her own party.
Mr. DeMarco prevailed by a margin of more than 3-1 with the Democratic electorate. Now he faces a more formidable challenge in a North Hills district that has been increasingly fruitful territory for GOP candidates over the last two decades.
"It's about reform of government," Mr. DeMarco said of his campaign. "It's not about party, or the wave against Democratic candidates. It's about the culture of corruption in Harrisburg."
"That's the only thing DeMarco can talk about," Ms. Orie said. "I look forward to my day in court, [but] this election is about issues. No matter where he tries to go with this, I've shown to be a strong candidate in this district. I walk the walk, not just talk it."
When the charges against her and a third sister, Janine Orie, were announced, Ms. Orie denounced them as the product of a political vendetta by Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala Jr. The Republican contended that the local prosecutor, a Democrat, had taken aim at her in part because of her role in raising questions about the casino gambling involvement of several of Mr. Zappala's relatives, including his father, former state Chief Justice Stephen A. Zappala Sr.
The district attorney has dismissed the suggestion that the case, rooted in a tip from a former Orie intern, was motivated by any political or personal animus.
After the charges were announced, Ms. Orie, who had served as majority whip in the Senate since 2007, stepped down from her post in the Republican leadership. She said that was the only professional accommodation she had made to the charges, which are not scheduled to go to trial until well after the election.
She maintained that she had kept up a full schedule of legislative business. As the legislative session drew to a close, she said she had been focused on budget issues including municipal pensions.
She said the exploding state budget demands would lead the next Legislature to examine issues such as a partial privatization of state liquor stores and the need for tougher screening to reduce Medicaid eligibility errors, which drive up spending on the federal-state program.
And, she said, "For me, I continue to be intent on regulating gambling in Pennsylvania."
Mr. DeMarco insists that his campaign is about more than his opponent's legal troubles. He said that from a fiscal conservative's point of view, his record as a Ross commissioner compares favorably with her performance in Harrisburg.
Mr. DeMarco noted that Ross has held the line on property taxes throughout his tenure as commissioner. At the same time, he said, state government spending had soared under governors of both parties.
Ms. Orie argued that the Senate majority had served as a bulwark against the "insatiable" spending proposals of the Democratic administration.
"She's voted in the past for tax increases," the Democrat said. Ms. Orie said she had been an opponent of increases in the state's major broad-based taxes. The only tax increase she had favored, she said, was an increase in the levy on cigarettes.
But beyond Mr. DeMarco's efforts to remind voters of Ms. Orie's legal jeopardy, and their similar portrayals of themselves as guardians against government excess, few major differences on issues have emerged in the race.
Both candidates say they oppose tax increases. The rivals have relatively conservative positions on social issues. Both are opposed to abortion. Both are lawyers and graduates of Duquesne University Law School.
Ms. Orie, a former prosecutor, was elected to the state House in 1996. In 2000, she won her current seat in a special election, succeeding Melissa Hart, who had been elected to Congress. She defeated James Rooney, grandson of the Steelers founder Art Rooney, in the special election.
Ms. Hart had captured the formerly Democratic seat in a major upset in 1992. That 1992 race was a pivotal contest, helping to tip control of the state Senate to the Republicans.
The party's majority has grown more secure in the intervening years. No matter what happens in the 40th District this year, the GOP's Senate majority appears solid.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.