WASHINGTON -- Announced by the sound of a gong, China has invaded Pennsylvania's U.S. Senate race in a pair of television ads attacking Republican Pat Toomey.
The Joe Sestak campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee unveiled television spots this week that extend the class warfare arguments against Mr. Toomey from his time on Wall Street to his support for opening trade barriers with the world's most populous nation -- at the supposed expense of U.S. jobs.
The ads could prove most potent in Western Pennsylvania, where manufacturing jobs have left for nations with lower production costs, including China.
"Millionaire Pat Toomey, he's fighting for jobs -- in China," the DSCC spot begins, as a Chinese flag unfurls in the background accompanied by a gong sound.
"They're trying to leave voters with one big message -- Main Street versus Wall Street, jobs overseas versus jobs for Americans," said G. Terry Madonna, a professor at Franklin and Marshall College who has conducted polls in the Senate race.
"That's an easy concept to understand, and I do think it probably plays more in places where the job losses are the greatest."
Both the DSCC and the Sestak ad cite Mr. Toomey's vote to normalize trade relations with China in 2000. According to an Economic Policy Institute report -- also cited in both ads -- the growing trade deficit between the U.S. and China has resulted in more than 95,000 job losses in Pennsylvania from 2001-08.
The DSCC notes that Mr. Toomey, after leaving Wall Street and before moving to Allentown to help operate a chain of restaurants, spent a year in Hong Kong doing financial markets research for a billionaire named Ronnie Chan.
"Maybe he ought to run for Senate in China," the ad concludes.
The Toomey campaign took issue with the economic impact of trade with China -- citing the full-throated support President Bill Clinton gave trade normalization and the bounties that exports have brought Pennsylvania businesses -- but spokeswoman Nachama Soloveichik took the most umbrage at the portion of the Sestak ad claiming Mr. Toomey "admitted he doesn't care if American workers lose their jobs to cheap Chinese imports."
The citation the Sestak campaign used to back up the claim came from Mr. Toomey's book, "The Road to Prosperity," in which he expounds on the benefits of free trade and writes: "Certainly, substantial foreign subsidies (if not offset by tariffs) would result in fewer American cars sold, and consequently fewer American auto workers."
The problem with the not caring claim is that in the very next sentence, Mr. Toomey writes:
"This is a very real problem for those individual auto workers and their families and, as a society, we should have a serious discussion about the public policy options for helping them deal with this problem."
Ms. Soloveichik called the attack "a bald-faced lie and a sign of their desperation."
Sestak spokesman Jonathon Dworkin said the claim was fair because Mr. Toomey never proposed any policy to save those jobs.
One of the final pre-election votes in the U.S. House also played into the hands of the Sestak campaign's China-outsourcing argument: The House voted, 348-79, last week to give the Commerce Department the power to impose tariffs on countries that undervalue their currencies -- a measure targeting China and the supposedly undervalued renmibi.
All 19 members of the Pennsylvania delegation -- including seven Republicans -- voted for the bill, an attempt to give the Obama administration another tool to use against China after its repeated rhetorical pressure on currency had little effect. But Mr. Toomey would not have voted for the bill, Ms. Soloveichik said, because it could incite a trade war and "all the businesses and manufacturers and farmers in Pennsylvania that depend on being able to export goods and services to foreign countries would begin to suffer."
The bill was pitched by its backers -- including co-author Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Upper St. Clair -- as a way to keep American manufacturing from further eroding, and Mr. Toomey's opposition to the bill puts him in the political minority.
"It's another example, and it's a very current example, that shows how far to the right he is compared to the mainstream of Pennsylvania," Mr. Dworkin said.
With 31/2 weeks until Election Day, polling consistently has shown Mr. Toomey with a lead between 5 and 10 percent and a deluge of ads from the campaigns and outside groups has done little to move the needle.
In the May special election to fill the 12th Congressional District seat, Rep. Mark Critz, D-Johnstown, used job outsourcing as a major campaign theme in his successful defeat of Republican Tim Burns. The twin China strikes, Mr. Madonna said, are a play to union and blue-collar "Bob Casey Democrats" in the 12th and elsewhere in Western Pennsylvania.
"That's the kind of message that will work in that district," Mr. Madonna said.
"The fundamental question is: Does it work enough? Now they just started to run 'em, so we'll see. ... In my judgment, he's not closing the gap. Maybe this commercial will do it."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.