Finding major differences between U.S. Rep. Jason Altmire and Republican challenger Keith Rothfus was not easy Thursday night, as Mr. Altmire gave a master class on how to be right-wing Democrat.
Mr. Rothfus is trying to ride a Republican wave into Congress next month -- one energized by opposition to health care reform, bailouts and President Barack Obama. But that's been a tough road for the candidate, since Mr. Altmire has so often voted against Mr. Obama's agenda and is so willing to talk about it.
Again and again, in questions before a packed crowd of some 300 people at Penn State Beaver in Monaca, the two men said they agreed on major federal issues. The debate was sponsored by the Beaver County Chamber of Commerce.
Mr. Rothfus, an Edgeworth attorney, was forced to press Mr. Altmire on the minutia of bills, such as when the incumbent said he voted against the TARP bailout not once but twice. "He did vote against TARP, but he also voted against repealing the TARP," the Republican said.
In response to a question on whether to extend the Bush-era tax cuts due to expire at the end of the year, Mr. Altmire said he was one of 31 Democrats who asked House Speaker Nancy Pelosi not to hold a vote on the extension unless all income levels (including those of the wealthiest taxpayers) were included. "It is because conservative Democrats stood up to Speaker Pelosi and said you cannot do this that we did not have a vote" on the tax cuts, he said.
Mr. Rothfus then said the Democrat voted for 10-year budget resolutions in 2008 and 2009 that included the tax cuts expiring. "I welcome him to the keeping-taxes-low camp, but I do question the timing of this conversion," Mr. Rothfus said to laughs from the crowd.
Mr. Altmire then soberly explained that the resolutions assume current law (which mandates that the cuts expire, unless Congress intervenes). "That was not a decision made by me or Congress ... That's how government works."
Mr. Rothfus, who formerly worked in George W. Bush's faith-based initiatives office, was the surprise winner in the spring GOP primary over former U.S. Attorney Mary Beth Buchanan. He has run on a conservative platform critical of government spending and health care reform, and has done his utmost to tie Mr. Altmire to Ms. Pelosi.
But despite the "D" by his name, Mr. Altmire has proved harder to pin down than many Democrats this year -- the former UPMC lobbyist voted against Obama-backed health care and cap-and-trade proposals, against the 2008 TARP bailout, and joined Republicans in criticizing hot-button issues such as the proposed mosque near Ground Zero and domestic terror trials. He did vote for the 2009 stimulus package.
The McCandless Democrat has used a significant fundraising advantage over his challenger to run TV ads touting his independence from the Obama administration, and hitting Mr. Rothfus (a federal bailout critic) for doing legal work for a firm (Bank of New York/Mellon) that took TARP funds.
Mr. Altmire entered Congress in the Democratic takeover of 2006, beating incumbent Republican Melissa Hart, whom he bested again in 2008. But it is a classic swing district that voted for Republican John McCain by an 11-point margin two years ago, giving Mr. Rothfus a fighting chance of winning the seat.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.