While Pat Toomey portrayed his Democratic Senate opponent, Rep. Joe Sestak, as a serial supporter of bailouts, a new Sestak ad reminded voters of Mr. Toomey's praise for prominent and polarizing social conservatives.

Mr. Toomey appeared in a Wexford living room Wednesday to criticize a Sestak proposal to have the federal government assist homeowners whose property was worth less than their mortgage balances.

"It's fundamentally unfair to force people to pay for other people's mistakes," Mr. Toomey said as he derided a measure that would empower the Federal Housing Administration to restructure so-called underwater mortgages so that the homeowners' balance reflected the current market value of the property. Mr. Toomey called it a misguided attempt to spread the pain of imprudent mortgages to taxpayers who had no culpability for the losses.

"People who work hard and play by the rules should not have to pay for unfair bailouts," the Republican said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Toomey charged that the measure, which has not emerged from committee, would add $100 billion to the federal budget deficit. A Sestak spokesman responded that the bill did not call for new revenue and would be paid for in part by closing tax loopholes, with the balance coming from unspent appropriations from the TARP funds approved as part of the original Bush administration bank rescue measure.

"Middle-class Americans, through no fault of their own, were slammed by the Wall Street deregulation supported by Congressman Toomey that caused the recession and particularly devastated the values of people's homes," Mr. Sestak said in a statement. "Now millions more Americans facing foreclosure are not the only ones at risk. If they lose their homes, it lowers the value of property for everyone in the neighborhood."

As the rivals exchanged those criticisms, a new Sestak ad, airing in the Philadelphia media market, enlisted video clips of past Toomey statements to remind voters that Mr. Toomey is a social and fiscal conservative. The commercial includes words of praise from Mr. Toomey for two polarizing conservatives -- Sarah Palin and Rick Santorum.

In the commercial, Mr. Toomey is seen calling Ms. Palin "a spectacular governor," and noting that his voting record during his three terms in Congress was "hard to distinguish" from that of Mr. Santorum, a former senator who was ousted in a 2006 landslide victory by Sen. Bob Casey. At another point, the ad shows Mr. Toomey saying that he would support outlawing abortion in Pennsylvania along with prosecution of doctors who performed illegal abortions.

Mr. Toomey's communications director, Nachama Soloveichik, issued a statement contending that the ad "twists the truth," although she did not dispute any of its specific assertions. She also noted that the Republican's anti-abortion views are shared by many Pennsylvania Democrats.

"Pat Toomey joins Democratic Senator Bob Casey and the bipartisan majority of Pennsylvania's congressional delegation in holding the pro-life position," she said. "The one with the extreme position is Congressman Sestak, who routinely gets 100 percent ratings from far left pro-abortion groups, who votes for taxpayer funding of abortions, and who supports no restrictions whatsoever on abortions."