The two gubernatorial campaigns have started slinging the fertilizer on TV lately, and neither comes out smelling like a rose.

A new ad from the Tom Corbett campaign features families struggling to pay their liquor taxes and something Democratic opponent Dan Onorato denies saying about Gov. Ed Rendell. Spots from the Onorato team repeat flimsy claims about a two-decade-old tax vote by the Republican, taxpayer-funded cars and Bush administration economic policies.

It was bound to happen. While every poll consistently finds Mr. Corbett leading Mr. Onorato in the governor's race, surveys released last week said the race was tightening with one month to go. Those are textbook conditions for negative advertising, not only in their race but in the U.S. Senate and congressional races as well.

The Corbett team was up with a new 30-second spot that starts with a dubious claim, quoting from a Washington Post column and saying, "Dan Onorato calls Ed Rendell his role model." The problem is columnist David Broder did not directly quote the Allegheny County executive as saying that, and his campaign denies he said those words.

Advertise with us

"So David Broder's lying? OK," responded Corbett spokesman Kevin Harley. "So they would question the dean of all political writers?"

Aware of Mr. Rendell's toxicity this year -- his approval rating was 35 percent last week -- Mr. Onorato rarely talks about him on the campaign trail. Still, Mr. Onorato would certainly like to copy his fellow Democrat's ability to turn out the vote. Any Democrat would.

The Corbett ad next says "Onorato loves raising taxes," and the source there is the ultra-conservative Americans For Tax Reform, not exactly an objective source. Then it says "Onorato handed Allegheny County families their largest tax increase in history," over shots of people sweating over piles of tax returns. It doesn't say so, but the tax being referred to is the county alcohol tax, which went from not existing to a rate of 10 percent in 2008, before dropping to 7 percent a year later.

"Dan's record speaks for itself," answered Onorato spokesman Brian Herman. "He made some tough decisions and balanced the county budget every year without rasing property taxes."

(A parenthetical note: If your family is indeed sitting at home using a calculator to tally your alcohol taxes -- and does not own a bar -- you might want to drive the minivan, or better yet walk, to the nearest Alcoholics Anonymous meeting.)

Advertise with us

The ad then hits Mr. Onorato for supporting energy taxes -- saying they will affect job creation and utility costs -- which is fair game in this race and many others this year. While Mr. Corbett is against taxing Marcellus Shale gas production, that also puts him at odds with state leaders of his own party, who at least favor small taxes.

Mr. Onorato got a boost in his name recognition from a goofy ad in which he instructs viewers on how to pronounce his name. The day after he got that good news, his campaign began running two negative spots that repeat more fragile claims than Mr. Corbett's ad.

The first knocks Mr. Corbett for supporting a 1988 millage increase (along with other Republicans) as a commissioner in flood-battered Shaler. It also says the attorney general's office "abused taxpayer-funded cars," citing an online story about the office's use of 25 cars for a Philadelphia Gun Violence Task Force.

"You don't have agents arrest drug dealers in their own vehicles, or riding bicycles," Mr. Harley said.

As for budget increases by the attorney general's office -- another criticism in the ad -- Mr. Harley said they were tied to union agreements bargained by the Rendell administration.

Advertise with us

A second spot says Mr. Corbett "supported economic policies that cost thousands of jobs" -- a criticism that Mr. Herman said is about Mr. Corbett's support of George W. Bush. Mr. Corbett was certainly an ally of Mr. Bush -- and of his father, who appointed him U.S. Attorney for Pittsburgh in 1989 -- but to tie the state's attorney general to the global recession that began under Bush's watch is as distended as Elastigirl from "The Incredibles."

"That may be one of the biggest stretches in credibility I've ever seen, and I've been doing this for 27 years," Mr. Harley said.