HARRISBURG -- Kevin Boyle, a young Philadelphia Democrat, thinks he can do what the legislative pay raise scandal of 2005 didn't -- oust former Republican House Speaker John Perzel from the seat he's held for 30 years.
The Boyle-Perzel faceoff is one of several House contests on Nov. 2 where a challenger aims to knock out an incumbent of the other party. It's part of the larger battle for control of the state House for the 2011-12 session, which starts in January.
Democrats have controlled the House since January 2007, but for the 12 years before that, Republicans ran things. They're optimistic about retaking the helm now, with many analysts seeing this as a Republican year nationally.
Democrats hold a 104 to 99 margin in the House, so a net gain of three seats would give power back to the GOP. With Republicans virtually certain to retain lopsided control of the Senate (now 30 to 20), retaking the House would put both chambers in GOP hands.
The party in control gets to decide which bills move forward for votes and which ones die a quiet death, plus deciding who gets to chair several dozen legislative committees -- both of which are considerable levers of power at the Capitol.
For leaders of the 2011-12 Legislature, there's an added prize. Once a decade, the state's congressional district lines must redrawn to reflect population changes. To do that, the House and Senate must enact a piece of legislation, which gives leaders considerable influence over which towns and areas will be included in each district. That can affect who sits in Congress for the next 10 years.
"The November General Assembly elections are incredibly important, not just for the usual reasons, but also for the upcoming congressional district reapportionment," said Charlie Gerow, a Harrisburg political strategist. With Pennsylvania likely to lose one seat because population growth has been flat, he said, "the implications of this reapportionment are enormous."
Both parties are throwing a lot of time, effort, money, mailings and phone calls into races where an incumbent is viewed as vulnerable or where the seat is open because the incumbent is retiring.
Democrats think Mr. Perzel's seat is ripe for takeover, and there's no brotherly love involved in their opposition. While Mr. Boyle is making his first run for office, he knows the political game, having been an aide to a Philadelphia city councilman. He's also the brother of state Rep. Brendan Boyle, D-Philadelphia, whose district is adjacent to Mr. Perzel's.
Most House members from Philadelphia are Democrats, who far outnumber Republicans in the state's largest city, but northeast Philadelphia still has three GOP legislators, including Mr. Perzel.
Democrats have a slight voter-registration edge in Mr. Perzel's district but that hasn't stopped him from winning elections for 30 years. His tenure gives him wide name recognition, and since he was a GOP leader for years, first as majority leader and then speaker from 2003 to 2006, he's been able to bring home a lot of legislative grants.
He also has significant negatives. He was speaker in July 2005 when the pay raise was enacted in the middle of the night (and later rescinded due to voter anger). Then, in late 2009, Mr. Perzel was charged by Attorney General Tom Corbett, a fellow Republican, with dozens of counts of political corruption, including theft of services, conspiracy and conflict of interest. A trial is expected this winter.
"John Perzel is well-known and well-liked in his district, but now there's the dilemma of him being under indictment," said Philadelphia political consultant Larry Ceisler. "He's also an incumbent in a year of anti-incumbency," with polls showing many voters in a mood to oust lawmakers, regardless of party.
On the other side of the state, another former House speaker, Rep. Bill DeWeese, D-Waynesburg, also is fighting to retain his seat. He defeated a strong Democratic challenger in the May primary and now faces Richard Yeager, former GOP party chairman in Greene County, who says he's knocked on 5,000 doors in the district.
Like Mr. Perzel, Mr. DeWeese has been in office since the 1970s, and he also is facing corruption charges filed by Mr. Corbett. Mr. DeWeese said he's "not taking anything for granted" despite greater name recognition. He also is doing typical things like door-knocking and hand-shaking at community events.
Democrats and Republicans in the House both have aggressive legislators heading up their campaigns -- Rep. Dave Reed, R-Indiana, vs. Democratic Rep. Mike Gerber, D-Montgomery.
But this year, Democrats don't have the outside advantages they had in 2006 and 2008. Gov. Ed Rendell's popularity in winning re-election in 2006 helped Democrats gain control of the House. President Barack Obama's victory in 2008 helped state House Democrats add to their number.
Many political observers see the pendulum swinging back to Republicans, who are said to have an edge in enthusiasm due to the national surge of conservative tea party voters and Mr. Obama's decline in popularity.
Both parties have their eyes on state House districts where the incumbent isn't seeking re-election. Seven open seats currently held by Democrats and three held by Republicans are seen as especially competitive.
That would seem to give the GOP a better chance for gains. But Democrats say they have strong candidates and hope to hold onto all seven seats and maybe even pick up one or two GOP swing seats.
Most of the competitive open seats are in Eastern Pennsylvania. But one is in the west, the Washington County seat being vacated by Rep. Tim Solobay, D-Canonsburg, who is running for the state Senate seat of retiring Democrat J. Barry Stout.
Seeking to succeed Mr. Solobay are Democrat Brandon Neuman of North Strabane, a lawyer in a Pittsburgh firm, and Republican Cody Knotts, who runs a newspaper called the Weekly Recorder. Democrats have a 2-1 lead in voter registration, so Mr. Neuman would seem to have an edge.
Democratic incumbents who might have a hard time include Reps. James Casorio of Westmoreland County and Jaret Gibbons of Lawrence County.
Mr. Casorio is being challenged by George Dunbar, Westmoreland GOP chairman and a Penn Township commissioner, and the GOP has been growing stronger in Westmoreland County in recent years. Mr. Gibbons, seeking his third term, is facing Republican Michael See, a native of North Sewickley, Beaver County.
Mr. Gerow said Republicans also have their eye on Chester County, where they want to retake three districts that they've lost in recent years.
Those seats are now held by Democrats Paul Drucker, Barbara-McIlvaine Smith and Tom Houghton. Berks County Democrat David Kessler represents an area where conservative Republicans have become active. Democrat Rick Mirabito in Lycoming County also may be vulnerable.
Democrats, in turn, have their eyes on three seats in Western Pennsylvania that are now held by Republicans: Jim Christiana of Beaver County, Matt Gabler of Clearfield and Tim Krieger of Westmoreland.
Mr. Gerber said he remains optimistic despite recent polls showing Democrats lagging. He said Dan Onorato, the Democratic gubernatorial candidate, and U.S. Senate candidate Joe Sestak "are building momentum."
"The environment is improving for Democrats," he said. "We will hold and maybe even expand our majority."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.