HERSHEY, Pa. -- The candidates for governor traded criticisms on who could best cut spending and spur the state's economy last night as their first general election debate kicked off the stretch drive to the Nov. 2 election.

Before a business-friendly audience, both candidates said they would not raise state taxes while contending that their opponent was failing to tell the full story of their fiscal positions. With the national campaign climate seeming to favor the Republicans, the burden was on Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato to shake things up, but their generally civil exchange before the Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry offered no apparent catalyst for a dramatic change in the dynamics of their race.

Mr. Onorato repeatedly mocked Attorney General Tom Corbett for what he characterized as shifting interpretations of the Republican's months-old pledge not to raise taxes. Mr. Corbett took the Democrat's boast that he had not raised property taxes in seven budgets as an occasion to remind the audience that Mr. Onorato, in enacting a tax on alcoholic drinks to fund the Port Authority, had "created the largest single largest tax increase in the history of Allegheny County."

Mr. Onorato characterized the Republican tax pledge as a "hokey gimmick," insisting that his belt-tightening record in office avoided the need to sign a similar pledge. Mr. Onorato repeatedly said he would not raise taxes, with the exception of enacting a "competitive," severance tax on Marcellus Shale natural gas deposits.

Advertise with us

Mr. Corbett said such a tax would inhibit development of the gas industry. He argued that the state would still reap revenue from the burgeoning industry through royalty payments for drilling on state land and through the taxes levied on the growing income of private landowners.

The candidates split on the whether the state could afford new spending for education. Mr. Onorato said that by prioritizing and making cuts in other areas, the state could increase it share of basic education funding, a trend that he said would save the state money in the long run. Mr. Corbett said that the state simply could not afford basic education increases in the light of the state's looming deficits.

Mr. Onorato called that position a recipe for tax increases at the school district level across the commonwealth.

Mr. Corbett used a question from the moderator, broadcaster Ted Koppel, to once again walk back from a much criticized statement earlier in the campaign in which he suggested that many residents were spurning jobs in favor of unemployment compensation payments. As an aside he noted that, he believes that "the vast number of people on unemployment compensation are looking for employment."

I'm glad to see Tom changed his view on people on unemployment," Mr. Onorato observed.

Advertise with us

The two candidates shared numerous stages with one another and their primary rivals during the winter and spring, but this was their first face-to-face confrontation of the general election campaign. It came as Mr. Onorato faces the challenge of closing the polling advantage that Mr. Corbett has enjoyed for months. The latest results, released yesterday from Muhlenberg College, showed the Republican leading his rival with a margin of 46 percent to 37 percent.

That finding was consistent with other recent polling of the race.

The business group had hoped to host a debate between the Senate candidates as well, but Rep. Joe Sestak declined the invitation, citing a scheduling conflict. The Democratic nominee was in Pittsburgh for a fundraising event with Sen. John Kerry and Teresa Heinz Kerry.

Mr. Toomey and Mr. Sestak debated twice during the primary season. Both have said they would like to see debates before the election but so far none has been scheduled. Like his fellow Democrat, Mr. Onorato, Mr. Sestak entered the last month of the campaign trailing consistently in public polling.

"Joe is eager to debate. We're working with the Toomey campaign and hope to have a specific announcement about that soon," said Jonathon Dworkin, a spokesman for the Sestak campaign.

Mr. Toomey's exchange with the former "Nightline" host broke little new ground. Mr. Toomey reiterated his call for steps to curb the federal deficit. While his Democratic opponent was not on stage, Mr. Sestak's campaign rebutted from afar with a statement charging that Mr. Toomey's votes for Bush administration budgets had helped set the stage for soaring deficits.